Rahul calls SIR ‘treason’ as INDIA unites against ECI; MPs detained
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 7 October 2026
Summary
- Opposition parties marched from Parliament towards the ECI headquarters, Nirvachan Sadan. They demanded that SIR be scrapped, that deleted names be restored, and that CEC Gyanesh Kumar be sacked.
- Delhi Police stopped the march. Rahul Gandhi, the Leader of the Opposition (LoP) in the Lok Sabha, held a day-long sit-in at Akashvani Bhavan and called SIR "treason".
- He and other MPs were detained in the evening.
- The ECI said the Opposition's demand for a meeting at a venue outside its premises was "unusual" and could not be accepted. The BJP called the protest "political drama".
Key facts for Prelims
- Art. 324: ECI's superintendence, direction and control of elections. Art. 324(5): CEC removal like an SC judge; other ECs only on the CEC's recommendation.
- Art. 326: Universal adult suffrage for citizens aged 18+ not otherwise disqualified.
- RP Act 1950: Section 16 (disqualification for registration, e.g. non-citizen); Section 21(3) (special revision); Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 (procedure).
- Removal motion thresholds: 100 LS / 50 RS signatures. Inquiry under the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968. Special majority in both Houses.
- 2023 Act: Selection Committee = PM + Union Cabinet Minister + LoP (Lok Sabha). Tenure 6 years or age 65. No reappointment.
- Section 168, Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023: Every police officer may interpose to prevent, and shall to the best of his ability prevent, the commission of any cognizable offence.
- Alliance name: Indian National Developmental, Inclusive Alliance (INDIA).
- Art. 19(1)(b): right to assemble peaceably and without arms.
Data and details
- March began 10.30 a.m. from Makar Dwar, Parliament, behind a banner reading "Election Commission is compromised — Sack Gyanesh Kumar".
- Delhi Police stopped the march at 11 a.m., a few metres from Nirvachan Sadan, at Akashvani Bhavan.
- Slogans: "vote chor gaddi chodh" and "Gyanesh Kumar istifa do". Placards read "BJP hi CEC hai" and "Democracy not for sale".
- Protesters were first bused away around noon, after nearly two hours of sloganeering.
- Rahul Gandhi then insisted "This can't end here", proposed marching to India Gate, and found all roads blocked.
- He squeezed through the narrow pedestrian gate into the Akashvani Bhavan complex. K.C. Venugopal and Pawan Khera were initially stopped at the gate and later allowed in.
- Around 2.30 p.m., Indian Youth Congress and NSUI activists charged the iron gates. Many ran in, police shut the gates with them inside, and buses detained them. One activist climbed a police bus roof with an NSUI flag and was pulled down.
- The sit-in continued under a banyan tree. Staff of the complex had watched from the parapet wall for two hours.
- Around 6 p.m. the Congress reached out to all parties to join the sit-in.
- TMC's Derek O'Brien and Mahua Moitra, IUML's E.T. Muhammad Basheer and SP's Mohibullah Nadvi had been removed earlier and returned.
- Priyanka Gandhi Vadra (Wayanad MP) and K.C. Venugopal were at the sit-in; the Delhi Police later detained the leaders.
- Around 8 p.m. police cleared the campus, removing leaders one by one. Rahul Gandhi was dragged towards a minibus, resisting and trying to wriggle out of a window.
- The Hindu's report describes the INDIA bloc dharna as lasting more than eight hours. The ECI's statement was issued after Rahul Gandhi was detained from the Akashvani Bhavan site.
- Detainees were taken to Kingsway Camp police station and released at 10:15 p.m. The INDIA bloc will protest again on Wednesday.
- All 19 parties that attended the 30 September INDIA meeting were represented at the sit-in. AAP and DMK stayed away.
- Akhilesh Yadav (SP), Abhishek Banerjee (TMC general secretary), Sanjay Raut (Shiv Sena UBT) and Supriya Sule (NCP-SP) walked together.
- BJD, which keeps equal distance from the ruling side and the INDIA bloc, joined for the first time.
- Its Rajya Sabha MPs joined, and it was the first time BJD and Congress leaders shared a public platform.
- BJD's Lenin Mohanty said the party is not part of the INDIA bloc and joined to protect democratic institutions and the integrity of the poll process.
- Akhilesh Yadav accused the ECI of working for the BJP and of targeting "PDA" (Pichde, Dalit, Alpsankhyak: backward, Dalit and minorities). He also accused the government of using multiple measures to "steal the mandate".
- TMC's Abhishek Banerjee was seen raising slogans beside Rahul Gandhi.
- The ECI says it learnt through the media, until 4 p.m., that some MPs wished to meet it. Till 4 p.m. no political party had sought an appointment.
- At about 4 p.m. the Delhi Police conveyed that a delegation of MPs led by Rahul Gandhi wished to submit a memorandum. The DCP said the delegation had 240 MPs and the proposed venue was the Parliament House Annexe.
- The ECI called this "unusual". By its protocol, meetings are held only on ECI premises.
- It offered to send its senior-most officer on duty to receive the memorandum, calling this "unprecedented". The leaders declined.
- In 2025 the ECI laid down a procedure, communicated to all parties:
- a delegation seeks an appointment through its duly authorised representative;
- the meeting is held at a mutually agreed time.
- He called the protest "political drama" staged by Rahul Gandhi and said the ECI statement exposed the Congress's claims.
- He said no request for a meeting had come from the Congress or any INDIA constituent.
- He said Congress has 99 Lok Sabha and 30 Rajya Sabha MPs and the SP has 37, who he said were not at the site in the evening. He said TMC MPs were also absent and DMK and AAP stayed away.
- He said the exercise aimed to turn democracy into a monarchy. (Contested: the front-page report has TMC MPs rejoining the sit-in.)
- Cockroach Janta Party (CJP) founder Abhijeet Dipke said Maharashtra Police were sending notices to CJP workers to keep them from an October 10 protest at Jantar Mantar against the CEC. He said Rajasthan workers were also served.
- The notices, allegedly by Chandrapur Police under Section 168 BNSS 2023, advise workers not to join. He showed two, to Mayur Malkhede (Ballarpur) and Raj Jaykumar Badolo (Chandrapur).
- He asked why Maharashtra Police was behaving like Delhi Police.
Static–dynamic linkage
- The ECI is a constitutional body. Article 324 gives it superintendence, direction and control over elections and electoral rolls.
- Its independence rests on:
- security of tenure and a judge-like removal procedure for the CEC;
- protected service conditions (they cannot be varied to the CEC's disadvantage after appointment).
- A recognised gap: unlike the Supreme Court, CAG and UPSC, the ECI's expenses are voted by Parliament and not charged on the Consolidated Fund of India, which limits its financial autonomy.
- Because the Commission is so powerful, it is judged on neutrality as much as legality. Opposition attacks on the CEC test whether these safeguards also command public trust.
- Protest is a fundamental right, but it is subject to reasonable restrictions. The police power to prevent cognizable offences (Section 168, BNSS 2023) is the legal hook in the related CJP-notice episode.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Constitutional bodies (Election Commission, Art. 324); Representation of the People Act, 1950 (electoral rolls); GS2 – Governance: independence and accountability of regulatory/constitutional bodies. Also Art. 19(1)(b) (peaceful assembly).
Background primer
Election Commission of India (ECI)
- What it is:
- A permanent constitutional body under Article 324, vested with superintendence, direction and control of elections to the President, Vice-President, Parliament and State legislatures.
- Founded:
- Constitutionally established at the commencement of the Constitution (Art. 324). It became a multi-member body permanently in 1993. It briefly became multi-member in 1989, the extra posts were abolished in 1990, and the multi-member structure was restored in 1993.
- Members:
- The CEC and such number of other Election Commissioners as the President may decide.
Removal of the CEC (how a "sack the CEC" demand works legally)
Additional context
- Judicial position on SIR: In ADR vs ECI, the Supreme Court held that the ECI has the power to conduct SIR under Art. 324 read with the RP Act, 1950 and its Rules.
- The ECI may examine citizenship for inclusion in the roll, but this affects only electoral entitlement. It does not divest anyone of a claim to citizenship or foreclose the competent authority's decision under the Citizenship Act.
- The ECI was ordered to refer all persons deleted on citizenship grounds to the competent authority within four weeks.
- Earlier CEC-removal attempt: On 12 March 2026, notices seeking the CEC's removal were submitted in both Houses, signed by 130 Lok Sabha and 63 Rajya Sabha MPs. The Lok Sabha Speaker and the Rajya Sabha Chairman later refused to admit them, exercising powers under Section 3 of the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968.
- ECI's stated safeguards: Draft-roll publication with a claims-and-objections window (Forms 6, 7, 8), appeal to the District Magistrate and the Chief Electoral Officer, and Booth Level Agents nominated by political parties.
Mains dimensions
- Credibility of the umpire:
- The sharpest evidence is the ECI's handling of the meeting request. Its protocol (appointment through an authorised representative, ECI premises only) is formally defensible. It nonetheless offered only to send its senior-most officer on duty, which it called "unprecedented", to receive the memorandum from a delegation the police said had 240 MPs. The leaders declined.
- The CEC's judge-like tenure protection is meant to guarantee independence, not to guarantee public trust. Slogans like "BJP hi CEC hai" show a perception problem.
- Constitutional route vs street route:
- The removal remedy exists (100 LS / 50 RS signatures, an inquiry, special majorities). Mere political disagreement or criticism of an ECI decision is not by itself a ground for removal.
- Street protest therefore signals politics rather than law, and it aims to build pressure. Notices reportedly rejected earlier in 2026 push the Opposition towards agitation.
- Policing and the right to protest:
- Detaining the LoP and other MPs, and preventive notices to CJP workers in distant states, raise Art. 19(1)(b) vs public-order questions.
- The notices were under Section 168 BNSS, a power to prevent cognizable offences. Whether a planned peaceful protest in Delhi by workers based in Chandrapur amounts to one is the key legal question.
- Law-and-order is a State subject but Delhi Police reports to the Union Home Ministry. The Maharashtra and Delhi episodes were read together by the CJP leader.
- SIR's substance: The protest is the political face of SIR concerns. These include deletions, documentary burden on migrants and the poor, and fears of a de facto citizenship test. The SC has upheld ECI's power but required safeguards and referral of citizenship doubts to the competent authority.
- Coalition politics:
- The BJD's first joint appearance, with an explicit disclaimer of INDIA membership, shows a single-issue, institution-protection alignment.
- The AAP and DMK absence and the BJP's headcount claims show the INDIA bloc's limits.
- The BJP uses the ECI statement as its counter, an example of a constitutional body's press note becoming a partisan weapon.
- Way forward:
- Institutionalised, minuted ECI–party consultations with a standing protocol for large delegations.
- Publicly accessible SIR deletion data and appeal tracking.
- Strengthening ECI's administrative independence (own secretariat) and a more balanced selection process.
- Parity in removal protection for ECs, who can currently be removed only on the CEC's recommendation (Art. 324(5)).
- Charging ECI expenditure on the Consolidated Fund to strengthen financial autonomy.
Possible Mains question
**GS Paper II, 15 marks:** "The independence of the Election Commission is a basic feature of free and fair elections. In the light of the recent confrontation between the Opposition and the ECI over the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls, examine the constitutional safeguards for the Commission's independence and suggest measures to restore public confidence in it."
Related topics
- Article 324 and Mohinder Singh Gill (1977): plenary powers of the ECI
- Appointment and removal of CEC/ECs; 2023 Act; Anoop Baranwal (2023) judgment
- Representation of the People Acts 1950 and 1951 (electoral rolls vs elections)
- Art. 19(1)(b) and reasonable restrictions (Art. 19(3)); BNSS preventive-action provisions
- Anti-defection and coalition politics (INDIA bloc, NDA, non-aligned parties)
- See the companion notes on SIR-linked detentions in Chhattisgarh and on Form 7 misuse allegations.
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 7 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs