More demands on U.S. deal ‘very difficult’: Sitharaman
Source: The Hindu, 6 October 2026
Summary
Speaking at the Munich Leaders Meeting in New Delhi on Monday, Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman said the India–U.S. trade negotiations have reached a "plateau". Further demands or concessions are now "very difficult", although the deal is still not finalised. She said India's imports of Russian oil did not feature as a condition in the India–EU FTA talks. That FTA is set to be signed in December. She said tariffs have become weaponised and are displacing negotiation. French Minister Delegate for Europe Benjamin Haddad said the FTA sends a strategic political message that the two economies are loyal, predictable and reliable partners.
Key facts for Prelims
- FTA: an agreement to cut or eliminate tariffs and barriers between the parties. The EU is India's 22nd FTA partner. The FTA was concluded at the 16th India–EU Summit.
- Ad valorem duty: a tax based on the value of imported goods.
- Section 122 of the US Trade Act 1974 allows a temporary tariff for 150 days. IEEPA is the US International Emergency Economic Powers Act.
- Reciprocal tariffs: tariffs a country sets to match another country's tariffs.
- Secondary sanctions: penalties imposed on third countries that keep trading with a sanctioned country.
- The India–EU FTA links 27 EU member states with India, covering roughly 2 billion people, a third of global trade and a quarter of world GDP.
Data and details
- Sitharaman's key claims:
- The U.S. deal is "yet to get finalised"; it has been "hard and very rigorously negotiated".
- Both sides have "reached a plateau" beyond which giving or taking is "very difficult".
- India has a "substantial trade surplus" with the US, which the US wants to address.
- India's trade imbalance with China "since 2014 has been growing exponentially". She asked "to what extent beyond negotiation can you go" if imbalance alone is the criterion.
- She said "Tariffs have become weaponised." India cannot take a similar tariff position against China and must "talk it out" and negotiate.
- The Graham Act provides a tariff of up to 100% on major buyers of Russia's oil and gas. In Europe, "there is no equivalent of a Lindsey Graham Bill", and no card on the table saying Russian purchases would determine the next negotiating step. She added that "a lot of things get discussed, formally and informally".
- India–EU FTA: set to be signed in December 2026. Russian oil was not a condition.
- Haddad: the FTA signals that the two economies are "loyal, predictable and reliable" partners. He pressed for integration of economies and a "world of cooperation and multilateralism" as trade relations get weaponised.
- Venue and format: Munich Leaders Meeting in New Delhi; the Front Page carried a shorter version of the same story.
Static–dynamic linkage
A trade surplus means exports exceed imports. A surplus with the US makes India a target of US "reciprocal tariff" policy. Tariffs have shifted from a bargaining tool to an instrument of geopolitical coercion, for example by penalising purchases of a third country's oil. FTAs are the opposite approach. They are a legal framework of tariff and rule-based preferences, concluded with a partner after negotiation and ratification. India's strategy is to diversify (EU, UK, EFTA) while negotiating with the US.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – IR: Bilateral groupings and agreements; effect of policies of developed countries on India's interests. GS3 – Economy: Trade policy, balance of trade, tariffs, FTAs, external sector.
Background primer
India–U.S. trade negotiations (interim agreement and the proposed Bilateral Trade Agreement)
- What it is:
- A negotiated arrangement to cut US tariffs on Indian goods and open Indian markets for US goods and energy.
- Founded:
- The BTA negotiations were launched by Trump and Modi on 13 February 2025. A US–India Joint Statement of 7 February 2026 set out a framework for an Interim Agreement, the first tranche of the broader BTA. Under it the US applies an 18% reciprocal tariff, and the additional 25% Russia-oil-linked tariff was removed. Finalisation was disrupted by the US Supreme Court ruling of 20 February 2026.
- Mandate:
- India agreed to eliminate or reduce tariffs on US industrial goods and a range of agricultural products.
- Why it matters:
- The US had imposed a 50% tariff on India's goods exports, made up of 25% reciprocal tariffs plus 25% related to India's Russian oil purchases.
India–EU Free Trade Agreement
- What it is:
- A comprehensive FTA covering goods, services and rules between India and the 27-member EU.
- Founded:
- Modi and EC President von der Leyen announced its conclusion at the 16th India–EU Summit on 27 January 2026. Talks began in 2007, were suspended in 2013 and revived in 2022.
- Mandate:
- The EU opens 97% of its tariff lines, covering 99.5% of India's exports by value. India liberalises 92.1% of tariff lines, covering 97.5% of EU exports, while protecting dairy, cereals, poultry and soymeal.
Lindsey O. Graham Sanctioning Russia and Iran Act of 2026 (US)
- What it is:
- US legislation giving the President power to impose tariffs on major buyers of Russian oil and gas. The article says up to 100%.
- Founded:
- The Senate passed the bill, renamed for Senator Graham, by an 86–11 vote. StudyIQ reports that President Trump signed it into law on 18 September 2026.
- Mandate:
- Allows 100% tariffs on goods from the top five importers of Russian oil and gas. It extends the Iran Sanctions Act of 1996 to 2031.
- Why it matters:
- The sponsors claim such trade fuels the Ukraine war.
Additional context
- Tariff removal: The US announced the removal of the additional 25% tariffs on Indian goods, effective 7 February 2026. The US administration said compliance would be monitored, and the US Secretary of Commerce could review and recommend reimposing the duty if Russian oil imports resumed.
- Reports say India committed to halting direct and indirect Russian oil imports, but Indian officials have not confirmed it. In the framework, India expressed its intention to buy $500 billion of US energy products, aircraft and parts, precious metals, technology products and coking coal over 5 years.
- US court ruling: On 20 February 2026 the US Supreme Court ruled the reciprocal tariffs unlawful, and India became subject to a 10% global tariff. The ruling disrupted the timeline for finalising the deal.
- Reciprocal tariffs imposed under IEEPA were invalidated and replaced by a 10% tariff under Section 122 of the Trade Act 1974 for 150 days from 24 February 2026.
- Oil waiver: On 6 March 2026 the US Treasury issued a 30-day waiver allowing Indian refiners to buy Russian crude stranded at sea.
- Graham Act scope: The Senate version did not name countries and referred to the five largest importers of oil and gas by volume. A House amendment made public on 14 September 2026 named India among the countries for possible 100% duties. Whether the enacted text names India was not confirmed from a trusted source.
Mains dimensions
- Limits of bargaining: a "plateau" means India has reached its red lines. These are likely to be sensitive areas such as agriculture and dairy, though the article does not say which. The final text of the deal is not public.
- Weaponisation of tariffs: Sitharaman contrasts negotiation, the old platform for addressing imbalances, with coercive use of tariffs. Her China example points out that a surplus-based logic, applied evenly, would let India impose tariffs on China. India cannot, which shows the asymmetry of power in trade.
- Energy security vs strategic autonomy: linking tariffs to Russian oil purchases tests India's multi-alignment. India's oil import dependence is high, and Russian crude was discounted. Replacing it raises costs and the current account deficit risk.
- Conditionality contrast: the US ties tariffs to Russian oil through domestic law (the Graham Act). The EU, according to the minister, does not. This shapes India's tilt towards the EU FTA and diversification of markets.
- Strategic hedging: Haddad's message that India–EU is "loyal, predictable and reliable" frames the FTA as a response to unpredictable US trade policy. The FTA gives Indian labour-intensive exports duty-free access.
- Transparency and oversight: the deal's text is not public, and Parliament has had limited discussion. This is a governance issue for trade treaties, where the executive negotiates and Parliament does not ratify.
- Way forward: diversify (EU, UK, EFTA, Gulf), insist on carve-outs for sensitive sectors, strengthen domestic manufacturing competitiveness, and keep energy sourcing diversified.
Possible Mains question
**GS2/GS3, 15 marks:** "Tariffs and sanctions have become instruments of geopolitical leverage. Discuss how this affects India's trade negotiations with the US and EU and its quest for strategic autonomy."
Related topics
- WTO principles: MFN, national treatment; FTAs under GATT Article XXIV
- Balance of trade vs balance of payments; current account deficit
- India's FTAs: UK, EFTA (TEPA), and the EU's CBAM
- India–Russia energy and defence ties; the US sanctions regime
- Trade agreements and parliamentary oversight in India
Topics: GS2Economy
All current affairs of 6 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs