SC rules out total ban on firecrackers for Deepavali
Source: The Hindu, 1 October 2026
Summary
- A Supreme Court Bench headed by Justice M.M. Sundresh ruled out a nationwide firecracker ban ahead of Deepavali. It accepted CSIR-NEERI's suggestion of a "limited and conditional relaxation".
- The relaxation covers manufacture of barium-free "next-generation joined green crackers" that meet noise, emission and safety norms.
- The Court said it would not allow round-the-clock bursting anywhere. It will consider fixing specific time windows. The Centre and CPCB got more time to continue barium and joined-cracker decibel tests.
Key facts for Prelims
- Green crackers are certified by CSIR-NEERI. Registration needs a PESO explosives licence.
- Barium-based compositions are not permitted as green crackers. The Court's 2025 order also barred firecrackers containing barium.
- Noise ceiling recommended by NEERI: 125 dB(AI) / 145 dB(C) peak.
- The regime stems from the Arjun Gopal judgment of 23 October 2018, which brought a strict regulatory regime for green crackers.
- Art. 51A(g) makes protecting the natural environment a fundamental duty of citizens.
- Institutions in the matter: CSIR-NEERI (formulations/testing), PESO (explosives licensing), CPCB (testing and monitoring), the Centre (before the Court through the ASG). CAQM has also filed reports before the Court.
- Dated: Supreme Court hearing on Wednesday (30 Sept 2026). ASG Aishwarya Bhati appeared for the Centre.
Data and details
- NEERI's tests show a 30% reduction in emissions compared with conventional joined crackers.
- Smaller shell size cut solid-waste generation by 4% up to 32%.
- Bursting time duration is five times longer in next-generation joined green crackers.
- Noise limit: 125 dB(AI)/145 dB(C) peak. NEERI also prescribed shell size, shell number and bursting duration, and said crackers must be free of banned chemicals.
- The series was developed without barium. It differs from conventional crackers in shell/tube size, formulation, bursting duration and frequency of bursting. Noise, particulate emissions and solid waste fall correspondingly.
- Manufacture must be by duly licensed manufacturers, to formulations tested and approved by the competent authority.
- Court's stance: a total ban would hurt sentiments, so it will not agree to one nationwide. It will not permit 24-hour bursting because of the effect on the sick, elderly and children.
- CPCB and the Union government were given more time to continue barium and joined-cracker decibel tests.
Static–dynamic linkage
The Supreme Court treats a pollution-free environment as part of the right to life under Art. 21. It balances this against livelihoods and cultural practice through a continuing mandamus. Art. 51A(g) makes protecting the natural environment a fundamental duty of every citizen. The same long-running petition (Writ Petition (C) No. 13029 of 1985) has produced successive regulatory orders. The approach is "regulate by science", with an expert body setting norms and the Court converting them into binding conditions. The alternative is an outright ban.
Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Environment: pollution & degradation (air, noise); GS2 – Judiciary: judicial role in environmental governance (Art. 21, Art. 51A(g)).
Background primer
Green crackers
- What it is:
- Eco-modified firecrackers developed by CSIR–NEERI to cut particulate matter, toxic gases and noise compared with conventional fireworks.
- Founded:
- In January 2018, eight CSIR institutes began developing reduced-emission fireworks, with CSIR-NEERI assigned to coordinate. In October 2018 the Supreme Court banned sale, use and manufacture of crackers that weren't "green". In May 2019 it allowed bulk manufacture after CSIR trial samples were approved by PESO.
- Mandate:
- Cut emissions while keeping the product usable. The joint CPCB–PESO–CSIR-NEERI report on "New Generation Joint Firecrackers" concluded that green crackers emit 30% less than conventional ones.
- Why it matters:
- Barium-based compositions are excluded from green crackers, and the Court's 2025 order also barred firecrackers containing barium. Green formulations cut emissions through smaller shells, reduced chemicals and dust suppressants.
CSIR-NEERI (National Environmental Engineering Research Institute)
- What it is:
- A laboratory of the Council of Scientific & Industrial Research (CSIR) headquartered in Nagpur. It was set up in 1958.
- Mandate:
- It certifies green crackers. It also issues emission-test certificates and runs the registration and QR-code system (see above).
- Why it matters:
- Gives the Court an independent scientific body to set measurable standards instead of a blanket ban.
Additional context
- The 2025 template: The Supreme Court relaxed a year-long blanket ban on fireworks in Delhi-NCR for Deepavali 2025, allowing only NEERI/PESO-approved green crackers. Sale was permitted only from 18 to 20 October 2025. That order barred manufacture or sale of crackers joined in series (laris). The 2026 position is more permissive: NEERI now recommends barium-free "next-generation joined" green crackers.
- Court's earlier caution: On 3 April 2025 the Court said it would not reconsider earlier orders unless pollution from "so-called green crackers" was shown to be at a bare minimum.
- Enforcement problem: NEERI reported multiple instances of QR codes being sold to unregistered manufacturers.
- Emission range: NEERI has said its green compositions cut particulate emissions by at least 30%, ranging up to 80%.
Mains dimensions
- Balancing test: The Court sets a middle path between health (winter air-pollution anxiety, vulnerable groups) and livelihood and cultural sentiment. This matches the "sustainable development" approach of earlier orders.
- Science-led regulation: The relaxation rests on a CSIR-NEERI report, with measurable specifications (dB limits, shell size and number, bursting time) instead of a moral or blanket prohibition.
- Evidence still provisional: CPCB/Centre decibel tests for barium and joined crackers are still running. The time windows are not yet fixed. The 30% reduction is only relative to conventional joined crackers. It is not zero emissions.
- Time-window regulation: A cap on hours of bursting addresses noise exposure and peak pollution load. The longer bursting duration of the new crackers (5x) makes the windows important to enforce.
- Enforcement gaps: QR-code misuse, unlicensed manufacture and inter-state flows weaken any relaxation (see 2b). Police and Pollution Control Board capacity is the weak link.
- Federal and governance angle: Centre (ASG), CPCB, state pollution boards, district police and the PESO licensing regime all share responsibility. Policy is made through Court-monitored orders, which raises the question of judicial overreach versus executive inaction.
Possible Mains question
**GS3 (Environment), 15 marks:** "The Supreme Court's approach to firecrackers reflects a tension between environmental protection, livelihoods and cultural sentiments. Examine the role of green crackers in resolving this tension and the challenges in enforcement."
Related topics
- Air pollution: sources, CPCB, National Clean Air Programme, CAQM (Delhi-NCR)
- Noise Pollution (Regulation and Control) Rules, 2000 under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986
- Art. 21, Art. 48A, Art. 51A(g); principles of sustainable development and the precautionary principle
- Role of the National Green Tribunal and the "continuing mandamus" in environmental litigation
Topics: GS3Environment
All current affairs of 1 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs