BrainParrot

Govt. causing an ecological disaster in country: Cong.

GS3Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 1 October 2026

Summary

  • Congress leader and former Environment Minister Jairam Ramesh said the Union government is "mindlessly" going ahead with an "ecological disaster" in the ₹92,000-crore Great Nicobar Island project.
  • He was reacting to The Hindu's report that the Union government moved the Supreme Court to stay hearings in the Calcutta High Court, where petitions allege that Forest Rights Act, 2006 provisions were violated in obtaining consent.
  • Ramesh hoped the Supreme Court would let the final HC hearings continue, and said the clearances and impact assessment reports are "deeply flawed" and of "dubious value".

UPSC relevance: GS3 — Environment: EIA/forest clearances, biodiversity; GS2 — Polity: Forest Rights Act, tribal rights, judiciary

Key facts for Prelims

  • Forest Rights Act, 2006 (Ministry of Tribal Affairs): recognises individual and community forest rights, including 13 categories of rights.
  • Gram Sabha → Sub-Divisional Level Committee → District Level Committee is the claim sequence.
  • FRA-related Gram Sabha consent for diversion stems from the MoEF's 2009 circular under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980; forest clearance has Stage-I and Stage-II.
  • The Shompen are a PVTG; the Nicobarese are a Scheduled Tribe but not a PVTG. Great Nicobar is the southernmost island of the Andaman and Nicobar Islands and includes the Great Nicobar Biosphere Reserve.
  • NGT adjudicates environmental clearances; High Courts hear forest-clearance and FRA challenges via writs.
  • The Calcutta High Court's jurisdiction includes the Union Territory of Andaman and Nicobar Islands.
  • Niyamgiri (2013): Gram Sabha role in forest diversion.

Data and details

  • Project cost as given in the article: ₹92,000 crore.
  • The Union government filed a petition in the Supreme Court seeking a stay of further proceedings in the Calcutta High Court matter (reported by The Hindu on Wednesday).
  • Allegation before the High Court: Forest Rights Act, 2006 provisions were violated in obtaining consent for the project.
  • Ramesh's claims: "various approvals under environment and forest laws have been deeply flawed" and impact assessment reports are of "dubious value".
  • The petitioner is described as a very senior former official of the Union Environment Ministry and the Ministry of Tribal Affairs. The Calcutta HC upheld her right to file the challenge; the government had questioned that right, and is now making the same argument in the Supreme Court.
  • Ramesh called the High Court petitions a "faint glimmer of hope" and hoped the Supreme Court would let the final hearings proceed as scheduled.

Static–dynamic linkage

A strategic infrastructure project on an ecologically sensitive island with Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups sets development against conservation and tribal self-determination. The legal question is procedural: under forest-diversion rules, forest rights must be settled and Gram Sabha consent obtained before diversion. The dispute in court is therefore less about whether the project is desirable than whether the process complied with the Forest Rights Act (FRA). The Union's attempt to halt the High Court hearing, and its objection to the petitioner's standing, raises a public-interest litigation issue (who can challenge) alongside the substantive FRA question.

Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Environment: Conservation, EIA, forest and coastal clearances; GS2 – Polity/Social Justice: Forest Rights Act, Gram Sabha, rights of Scheduled Tribes and PVTGs; Judiciary (locus standi, forum selection).

Background primer

Forest Rights Act, 2006 (Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act)

What it is:
an Act to recognise and vest forest rights and occupation in forest land in forest-dwelling Scheduled Tribes and other traditional forest dwellers who have resided in forests for generations but whose rights could not be recorded.

Great Nicobar Island project (Holistic Development of Great Nicobar Island)

What it is:
a mega-infrastructure project developing parts of Galathea Bay, Pemmaya Bay and Nanjappa Bay. It includes a transhipment port, an airport, a power plant and a township, needing about 13,000 hectares of forest land.

Additional context

  • Government position: the Centre says the project has an NOC from the Ministry of Tribal Affairs, with due adherence to the FRA. Since the islands already have over 75% forest cover, compensatory afforestation is planned in Haryana rather than locally. Tree felling is phased: 2.79 lakh trees in Phase I (2025–2035), 3.41 lakh in Phase II (2036–2041) and 0.91 lakh in Phase III (2042–2047). An area of 65.99 sq km is to be retained as a green area with no felling.
  • Critics' evidence: Gram Sabha resolutions were signed by settlers who are not stakeholders under the FRA, and at least 60 signatures repeated across resolutions. They were held at different venues on the same day with identical wording. Petitioner Meena Gupta noted that FRA committees were formed only two months before the Gram Sabhas, though the Act was 14 years old.
  • Later developments reported after this issue date: on 5 October 2026 the Supreme Court declined the Union's plea to stay the High Court proceedings, saying preservation of indigenous culture is a constitutionally protected fundamental right. The High Court scheduled its next hearing for 25–26 November 2026. On 30 October 2026 the Ministry of Tribal Affairs told the High Court that four Nicobarese applicants were not "necessary or proper parties" and had bypassed FRA remedies.

Mains dimensions

  • Development vs ecology vs tribal rights: the project's strategic logic (port, airport, Indian Ocean presence) must be balanced against loss of primary tropical forest, marine ecosystems (nesting grounds, corals) and a seismic zone, and the survival of PVTGs.
  • Procedural legality of consent: the FRA process works only if Gram Sabhas are lawfully constituted, representative and consulted before diversion is irreversible. Allegations of settler-signed, near-identical resolutions and late-formed committees go to whether consent is free, prior and informed.
  • Conflict of laws: 1956 Aboriginal Tribes Regulation (diversion without Gram Sabha consent) vs FRA 2006. Clearances under the 1980 Act rely on executive circulars rather than express statutory consent.
  • Institutional design: NGT approving clearances while the HC examines the FRA process shows fragmented forums. Efforts to stay the HC proceedings raise the question of whether complex projects get comprehensive scrutiny or piecemeal review.
  • Locus standi in public interest litigation: objection to a former senior official's standing, rejected by the HC and re-argued in the SC, is a test of how open courts remain to expert petitioners.
  • Transparency of EIA: off-site compensatory afforestation (planned in Haryana, because the islands already have over 75% forest cover) and the contested consent process raise questions about the credibility of EIA and the precautionary principle.
  • Way forward: an independent review of FRA compliance, multi-season biodiversity assessment, strict phasing with monitoring, genuine consultation of Nicobarese and Shompen institutions, and clear judicial timelines.

Possible Mains question

**GS3, 15 marks:** "Large infrastructure projects in ecologically fragile and tribal areas raise questions about procedure as much as about substance. Examine with reference to the Great Nicobar project and the Forest Rights Act, 2006."

Related topics

  • EIA Notification, 2006; ICRZ Notification 2019; Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and 2023 amendment
  • PESA Act, 1996; Fifth and Sixth Schedules; Article 244
  • PVTGs (Shompen) versus other Scheduled Tribes (Nicobarese); Andaman and Nicobar Islands (Protection of Aboriginal Tribes) Regulation, 1956
  • National Green Tribunal Act, 2010; precautionary principle, sustainable development
  • Niyamgiri, Samatha, Vedanta cases; free, prior and informed consent

Topics: GS3Environment

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 1 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs