Recall split verdict in CEC appointment case: petition
Source: The Hindu, 30 September 2026
Summary
- The lead petitioner challenging the 2023 Act on the appointment of the CEC and Election Commissioners filed a curative petition in the Supreme Court on Tuesday. It seeks to recall the September 23 split verdict, citing "reasonable apprehension of bias".
- The allegation is that the son of Justice Satish Chandra Sharma, one of the two judges, serves as standing counsel for the Election Commission of India (ECI). The petitioner says she learnt this from media reports after the judgment and verified it on the High Court's website.
- The split verdict has stalled the immediate hearing on the merits of the Act.
Key facts for Prelims
- Article 324(2): the President appoints the CEC and ECs, subject to any law made by Parliament.
- The 2023 Act repeals the Election Commission (Conditions of Service of Election Commissioners and Transaction of Business) Act, 1991.
- Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India (2023): a Constitution Bench ruling that created the interim PM–LoP–CJI committee.
- Selection Committee under the 2023 Act: PM, a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the PM, and the LoP/largest opposition party leader in Lok Sabha.
- Article 145(3): a Bench of at least five judges for cases involving a substantial question of constitutional interpretation.
- Eligibility: current or former holder of a post equivalent to Secretary to the Government of India.
- Tenure: six years or up to age 65, whichever is earlier.
Data and details
- Split verdict: September 23. Curative petition filed on Tuesday (the day before this issue).
- Justice Dipankar Datta (lead judge on the Division Bench) declined a reference to a five-judge Constitution Bench. Justice Satish Chandra Sharma held the petitions should be heard by a Constitution Bench.
- The ground for recall is "reasonable apprehension of bias". The allegation is that Justice Sharma's son is standing counsel for the ECI. The petitioner says she learnt of this after the judgment, from media reports, and then checked the High Court website.
- The split verdict stalled the immediate hearing on the merits of the Act.
- The 2023 Act replaced the CJI with a Union Minister on the three-member panel, giving the government a dominant role in appointments.
- 2-to-1 executive majority on the committee (per petitioners).
Static–dynamic linkage
Article 324(2) says the President appoints the CEC and ECs, subject to any law made by Parliament. For over seven decades there was no such law, so the executive effectively decided. The Supreme Court's 2023 Anoop Baranwal ruling laid down an interim committee (PM, Leader of Opposition, CJI). Parliament's 2023 Act then replaced the CJI with a Union Cabinet Minister. The challenge asks whether Parliament may legislate away a Constitution Bench's safeguard. The current episode adds a second layer: procedural fairness and bias apprehension within the Court itself.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Constitutional bodies (Election Commission, Article 324); separation of powers; judicial processes (Constitution Bench reference, curative petitions, judicial propriety).
Background primer
Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023
- What it is:
- A statute that repeals the 1991 Act and sets out the appointment process and service conditions of the CEC and ECs. It implements Article 324(2) by creating a law on ECI appointments, replacing the earlier practice of appointments on the Union executive's advice.
- Founded:
- Introduced in the Rajya Sabha on 10 August 2023 as a Bill (PRS records the introduction date as August 10, 2023). It followed the Anoop Baranwal judgment of March 2023.
- Mandate:
- Candidates must have integrity and election-management experience, and hold or have held a post equivalent to Secretary to the Government of India. CEC and ECs receive a Supreme Court judge's salary and serve six years or until age 65, whichever is earlier. The Committee may consider names beyond the five shortlisted. Its recommendations are valid despite a vacancy in the Committee.
- Why it matters:
- To give effect to Article 324(2) through law rather than executive discretion.
Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India (2023)
- What it is:
- A Supreme Court judgment of March 2, 2023 (Writ Petition (C) No. 104 of 2015). It laid down that the CEC and ECs be appointed by a committee of the PM, the CJI and the Leader of Opposition.
- Why it matters:
- The Constituent Assembly intended an independent Election Commission whose appointment is regulated by law, not decided by the executive.
Curative petition (static)
Additional context
- A two-judge Bench of the Supreme Court had split on whether to refer petitions against the 2023 Act to a larger Constitution Bench. One judge cited Article 145(3), which requires a Constitution Bench for substantial constitutional questions.
- The other judge held no larger reference was needed, since the five-judge Baranwal bench had already established that ECI appointments must be free from executive influence.
- The pleas challenge Section 7 of the Act. The petitioners say the committee's structure gives the executive a two-to-one majority and undermines ECI's independence.
- In an earlier hearing the Supreme Court termed the appointment mechanism "Tyranny of the Elected" while hearing this challenge.
- The Selection Committee can statutorily ignore the Search Committee's five-name shortlist entirely.
- Earlier proposals: the Tarkunde Committee (1975) and the Law Commission's 255th Report (2015) recommended a three-member committee of PM, LoP and CJI. The Goswami Committee (1990) recommended that the President consult the CJI and the LoP.
Mains dimensions
- Executive dominance vs. institutional independence: The Act replaced the CJI with a minister. The PM and his nominee outvote the LoP two-to-one, and the committee can set aside the search committee's shortlist.
- Separation of powers: Can Parliament legislate to dilute an interim safeguard created by a Constitution Bench under Article 324(2)? The Baranwal logic is that executive-only appointments compromise independence.
- Judicial propriety and procedural fairness: A curative petition is invoked on "apprehension of bias" based on a judge's family member's professional link with a party before the Court. This highlights disclosure norms, recusal and the maxim that justice must be seen to be done.
- Institutional delay: The Bench split over whether to refer the matter to a Constitution Bench, so the merits remain unheard. Meanwhile the ECI continues major exercises such as the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls.
- Comparative and reform ideas: A PM–LoP–CJI committee was recommended by the Tarkunde Committee and the Law Commission (255th Report), while the Goswami Committee urged consultation with the CJI and LoP. Broader parliamentary panels (including the Speaker and LoPs of both Houses) were suggested by the NCRWC (2002) and the 2nd ARC (2007). The simplest option is to restore the CJI.
- Constitutional silence: Article 324 left appointments to Parliament's law for seven decades, and the gap was filled by executive practice until 2023.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners Act, 2023 has been criticised for diluting the independence of the Election Commission. Critically examine, in light of the Anoop Baranwal judgment."
Related topics
- Article 324 and ECI's powers, composition and removal (CEC removal like a Supreme Court judge)
- Constitution Bench references (Article 145(3)) and the role of the CJI as "master of the roster"
- Curative petitions, review petitions, recusal and judicial ethics
- Other selection panels with judicial/Opposition participation (CBI Director, CVC, Lokpal)
- SIR and electoral roll integrity
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 30 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs