State govts. stumped by demography committee’s ‘religion-wise’ inquiries
Source: The Hindu, 29 September 2026
Summary
- The Home Ministry's High-Level Committee on Demographic Changes (HLCDC) has sent States a 35-question questionnaire that seeks religion-wise data. State officials say they cannot answer most of it because departments do not keep data under religious categories.
- Separately, the EC has not yet given the committee the data on people excluded from the SIR as suspected foreign nationals, despite a meeting with the committee last week.
- The story brings together three issues: secularism and state data collection, the immigration-driven demography agenda, and the electoral-roll citizenship check.
Key facts for Prelims
- HLCDC: constituted by the Ministry of Home Affairs. Chair: a retired Supreme Court judge. Includes the Census Commissioner. Member Secretary: Joint Secretary (Foreigners-I).
- The "High-powered Demography Mission" was announced by the PM on 15 August 2025 (Independence Day speech).
- Sachar Committee (appointed 2005 by the UPA government) studied the social, economic and educational status of Muslims.
- The Supreme Court (27 May, upholding the Bihar SIR): the EC can verify citizenship for inclusion or exclusion on the roll only. Names of 2003-roll electors purged as non-citizens go to the Centre, for adjudication by a competent authority under the Citizenship Act, 1955.
- Citizenship Act, 1955 (competent authority); RP Act, 1950 Sections 16 and 19 (roll eligibility).
- Religion-wise categories used in the questionnaire: Hindus, Sikhs, Christians, Muslims, Parsis and Buddhists.
Data and details
- Scope of the HLCDC's data demand:
- Religion-wise data for the past 15 years on birth registrations, vehicle registrations, school enrolment and property transactions.
- District-wise details of religious structures established in the past 15 years, including any GIS mapping or other technology used.
- District-wise unusual increases in Aadhaar, voter ID and ration card registrations.
- District-wise unusual school enrolment trends inconsistent with historical birth rates, with reasons.
- Intelligence assessments and commission reports on religious conversions among Scheduled Tribe communities.
- Details of operational detention centres.
- 35 questions in all. States asked to collate data on six communities across all categories.
- What States actually have: religion-wise data exists only for birth registration, where the certificate records the newborn's religion, and for the number of undocumented migrants apprehended or deported. Everything else is unavailable.
- State officials' stated reason: the Constitution's secular construct prohibits collection of data under religious categories.
- Background contrast: the BJP, as principal Opposition in 2006, opposed the Sachar Commission's recommendations and questioned their constitutional validity, calling them religious quotas and socially divisive.
- Supreme Court (27 May, Bihar SIR): the Court directed the EC to refer, within four weeks, the names of 2003-roll electors purged as non-citizens to the Centre.
- Current status:
- Government sources: the EC has not provided the data on persons excluded from the SIR as suspected foreign nationals.
- A committee member said the States had not responded yet. A meeting with EC officials was held last week.
- The EC did not respond to The Hindu's queries on the delay.
Static–dynamic linkage
The state may collect data for policy, but data classified by religion is sensitive. The Constitution makes the state religiously neutral but does not stop it from identifying disadvantage. The 2005 Sachar Commission is the reference point for religion-based socio-economic data. The BJP, as the principal Opposition in 2006, opposed it as promoting religious quotas.
The citizenship question also runs through the voter roll. The Supreme Court said the EC may verify citizenship only to the limited extent of deciding inclusion or exclusion. The question is who decides citizenship afterwards.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Secularism (Preamble, Articles 14–15, 25–28), citizenship (Citizenship Act, 1955), electoral rolls (RP Act, 1950); GS2 – Governance: data collection and policy design; GS3 – Internal security: illegal migration and border management.
Background primer
High-Level Committee on Demographic Changes (HLCDC) / Demographic Change Committee
- What it is:
- A committee constituted by the Government of India to study demographic changes arising from illegal immigration and other abnormal reasons, and to suggest measures.
- Mandate:
- To assess demographic changes due to illegal immigration and other abnormal reasons, analyse causes, and recommend policy, legislative and administrative measures. It is also asked to recommend a permanent mechanism for identification, detention and deportation of undocumented immigrants.
Special Intensive Revision and the citizenship check
Additional context
- The terms of reference include analysing population changes at the level of religious and social communities.
- The terms of reference also include recommending institutional and operational mechanisms for border management and for identification, detention and deportation of illegal immigrants.
- The Home Minister has said the committee is meant to identify causes and recommend corrective measures, including possible legal provisions.
Mains dimensions
- Secularism and data: The officials' objection is that departments do not keep religion-wise data, and that the Constitution's secular character disallows it. The Census has historically tabulated religion, and welfare targeting at religious minorities (Sachar) relied on such data. The real issue is purpose: using religion-wise data to detect "abnormal" change, which is a different purpose from measuring deprivation. The BJP's 2006 position against Sachar makes the political contrast sharp.
- Evidence quality: Questions like "unusual enrolment inconsistent with birth rates" or "unusual increases" in Aadhaar/voter ID/ration cards assume that such patterns reflect illegal migration. Without baseline data, such questions risk producing inference without evidence. States cannot supply religion-wise breakdowns because departments record what they need for administration, not religion.
- Citizenship adjudication: The Supreme Court limits the EC to roll-related verification, with a competent authority under the Citizenship Act deciding the rest. The EC has not yet given the HLCDC its data on SIR exclusions of suspected foreign nationals. This leaves open how roll-level findings will feed into the competent authority's citizenship determination.
- Federal and security angle: Data collection is asked of States, but religion-wise data would require new administrative systems. Law and order and demography have tribal and border dimensions (the committee's focus on ST conversion and detention centres).
- Rights and social harmony: Mapping religious structures and tying enrolment trends to communities can stigmatise minorities and strain social cohesion. Safeguards on data use, privacy and non-discrimination (Articles 14, 15, 21) matter.
- Way forward: Define the purpose and legal basis of the data request. Use existing legal sources (Census, civil registration) and scientific methods. Separate security questions from community-wise data. Ensure the final report is public and tested for evidence quality.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "Collecting religion-wise administrative data for studying demographic change raises both constitutional and practical concerns. Discuss, in the context of the High-Level Committee on Demographic Changes, how the state can address illegal migration while remaining true to secular and rights-based governance."
Related topics
- Secularism: Preamble, Articles 14–15, 25–28; S.R. Bommai (1994)
- Sachar Committee (2006) and minority welfare policy; Census Act, 1948 and Census of India
- Citizenship Act, 1955 (and amendments); Articles 5–11; Foreigners Tribunals; undocumented migrants
- Registration of Births and Deaths Act, 1969; Aadhaar and its limits as citizenship proof
- Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls (the roll-revision side of this issue)
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 29 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs