SC questions govt.’s power to levy UPI merchant fees
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 29 September 2026
Summary
- A three-judge Supreme Court Bench headed by CJI Surya Kant issued notice to the Union, RBI and NPCI on a petition against the September 14, 2026 notification that introduces a merchant discount rate (MDR) on certain UPI person-to-merchant (P2M) transactions.
- The Bench refused an interim stay. The MDR is to start from October 15, 2026.
- The Court questioned the legal character of the levy: whether it is a tax, a fee or something else, and what the Executive's power to impose it is. It asked for an affidavit on this.
Key facts for Prelims
- Section 10A, PSS Act, 2007 (inserted 2019): bars charges on prescribed electronic payment modes. It is now amended and under constitutional challenge.
- Zero MDR on UPI and RuPay debit cards ran from 1 January 2020. Section 269SU of the Income-tax Act is the companion provision.
- NPCI operates UPI and RuPay. RBI is the payment-system regulator under the PSS Act. The respondents are the Union of India, RBI and NPCI.
- MDR is a merchant-side fee, not a charge on the payer.
- Categories in the new regime: P2M (person-to-merchant) above ₹2,000 attracts MDR. P2P (person-to-person) is out of scope.
- Article 265 (no tax without authority of law) is the constitutional backdrop to the "tax or fee" question put by Justice Bagchi. The article does not cite Article 265 itself.
Data and details
- Fee structure per the government's submission:
- MDR of 0.4% on P2M UPI transactions above ₹2,000.
- Capped at ₹300 per transaction for transactions of ₹75,000 and above.
- Essential services capped at ₹5.
- ASG Venkataraman: 96% of gateway users are exempt, 4% are covered, and overall collection charges are under 0.5% with these limits.
- Dates: notification of 14 September 2026. MDR is likely to start on 15 October 2026. Respondents have four weeks to file counter-affidavits.
- Court's key query (Justice Joymalya Bagchi): if the charge is not a tax or fee, what is its character and what is the executive scope to "expropriate" it? An affidavit was sought.
- Government's defence:
- The charge touches a "scarce, thin" population.
- MDR is limited to aggregators and banks, who ensure instantaneous credit and debit to avoid cash.
- The government "takes nothing" and is "several steps away" from the money. It is a "purely administrative mechanism".
- Petitioner (Anjan Datta): MDR will push users back to cash and black money. He repeatedly sought a stay.
- Constitutional challenge: amended Section 10A gives "unguided" power to the Executive to decide which payment modes get no-charge protection. The petitioner pointed out that no-charge protection for RuPay debit cards continues without a monetary ceiling.
Static–dynamic linkage
Two questions are in play.
- Economic: who pays for payment infrastructure when the user-facing price is zero? The state subsidised UPI through a statutory "zero MDR" rule. Reversing it shifts costs back to merchants.
- Constitutional: the Court's question is whether a charge is a "tax" (which needs authority of law under Article 265), a "fee" (which needs a quid pro quo), or a private commercial charge. The petition alleges that amended Section 10A gives "unguided" powers to the Executive. This maps onto the excessive delegation doctrine and Article 14 arbitrariness (the analytical framing is the note's own; the article reports only the "unguided powers" allegation).
Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Economy: Banking and payment systems, digital finance, resource mobilisation; GS2 – Polity: Delegation of legislative power, executive action and rule of law (Article 265).
Background primer
Merchant Discount Rate (MDR)
- What it is:
- A fee that merchants pay to a payment processing company on debit or credit card transactions, typically a percentage of the transaction amount.
Section 10A, Payment and Settlement Systems (PSS) Act, 2007 and the zero-MDR regime
- What it is:
- Inserted by the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2019. No bank or system provider may impose, directly or indirectly, any charge on a person making or receiving payment through prescribed electronic modes.
- Why it matters:
- Zero MDR worked as a subsidy to move merchants and consumers away from cash.
NPCI, UPI and RuPay
Additional context
- The Finance Ministry proposed PSS Act amendments on 3 August 2026 to reintroduce MDR on select digital payment modes by removing the zero-MDR provision in Section 10A.
- Parliament passed the Taxation and Other Laws (Amendment) Bill, 2026. It amends Section 10A and removes the statutory bar on MDR on UPI and RuPay debit card transactions.
- Under the amended framework the government can notify fee-bearing payment channels, while pricing moves towards the NPCI steering committee.
- The Bill was passed as a Money Bill. The Rajya Sabha can only make recommendations on a Money Bill and return it to the Lok Sabha.
- Following the amendment, the Centre notified (S.O. 5067(E), 14 September 2026) that RuPay debit card transactions and UPI transactions up to ₹2,000 will not attract charges.
- NPCI later postponed the MDR rollout from 15 October to immediately after Diwali, a decision of the UPI and Services Steering Committee taken with the festive season in mind.
- Fiscal and operational backdrop: UPI handled ₹29.9 lakh crore in July 2026, with over 23 billion transactions. A March 2026 Parliamentary Standing Committee on Finance report said the absence of MDR makes the UPI ecosystem financially unsustainable.
- Government clarifications (PIB):
- MDR will apply to only about 4% of merchant transactions.
- Small merchants receiving up to ₹1 lakh a month through UPI QR codes continue to enjoy zero MDR.
- Essential and thin-margin sectors above ₹2,000 (railways, telecom, insurance, fuel, agricultural inputs) pay a flat ₹5. Capital-market payments pay 0.02%, capped at ₹300.
- MDR is not a charge on customers, and banks are advised to ensure merchants do not pass it on.
- Critique from the analytical literature: Government incentives covered only a fraction of UPI's actual cost and left banks with loss-making transactions. Deep-pocketed apps could absorb losses, helping two major players dominate the customer-facing market.
Mains dimensions
- Fiscal sustainability vs financial inclusion: Zero MDR helped UPI scale. The Standing Committee's view is that it is unsustainable. A calibrated MDR (0.4% above ₹2,000, caps at ₹300, ₹5 for essentials) tries to protect small merchants and essential services. A small share of transactions by count could still carry a larger share by value, which is worth probing in an answer.
- Legal character of the levy: The Court's tax-vs-fee question is dispositive. If the amount goes to banks and aggregators, it is neither a tax (which goes to the Consolidated Fund) nor a fee for state services. The government says it is an administrative mechanism within a private ecosystem. The Court wants this in an affidavit.
- Delegation and arbitrariness: Section 10A hands the Executive the choice of which payment modes are protected. The RuPay carve-out with no ceiling invites an Article 14 argument. This is the classic "unguided discretion" test.
- Behavioural and macro effects: The petition warns of a shift back to cash, with black-money and formalisation consequences. The government replies that the exempt base of 96% limits that risk.
- Market structure: Zero MDR concentrated the market in a few apps and strengthened NPCI's infrastructure position, according to critics. Revenue-sharing may fund fraud safeguards and rural expansion, but it needs robust pricing governance.
- Way forward: Transparent, rule-based pricing; periodic review; anti-pass-through safeguards for consumers; clear statutory guidance for executive notifications; a competition-neutral treatment of payment modes.
Possible Mains question
**GS3, 15 marks:** "India's zero-MDR policy for UPI is being reversed in part. Examine the economic rationale for, and the legal and distributional challenges of, charging merchants for UPI transactions."
Related topics
- Payment and Settlement Systems Act, 2007; RBI's role and payment system oversight
- Article 265; the tax–fee distinction; the doctrine of excessive delegation; Article 14 and manifest arbitrariness
- Financial inclusion: PMJDY, Aadhaar, UPI 123PAY, UPI Lite
- Digital Public Infrastructure and India's global payments leadership
Topics: GS3Economy
All current affairs of 29 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs