BrainParrot

Decide disqualification petitions against MLAs by Oct. 8, SC urges Bengal Speake...

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 29 September 2026

Summary

  • Three linked proceedings in the Trinamool Congress split dispute came up on Monday.
  • In the first, the Supreme Court declined to intervene directly. It urged the West Bengal Speaker to conclude by 8 October the disqualification proceedings under the Tenth Schedule, relying on the Meghachandra "reasonable time" rule.
  • In the second, it fixed a three-month window for the EC to decide the leadership dispute, counted from when the pleadings are completed.
  • In the third, the Calcutta High Court questioned the EC over its allotment of the "envelope" symbol, and reserved its order.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: Anti-defection law (Tenth Schedule), Speaker as Tribunal, ECI's power over party disputes

Key facts for Prelims

  • Tenth Schedule: 52nd Amendment (1985). Paragraph 6 gives adjudication to the Speaker/Chairman. The "split" paragraph (Paragraph 3) was omitted in 2003 (91st Amendment). The merger exception needs two-thirds of the legislators.
  • Meghachandra (2020): three months is the outer limit for the Speaker to decide, absent exceptional circumstances.
  • Subhash Desai (2023): a Constitution Bench in the Shiv Sena split case. The Speaker is the proper authority, and the Speaker and the ECI can proceed concurrently.
  • Election Symbols (Reservation and Allotment) Order, 1968: Paragraph 15 covers rival groups of a recognised party. The ECI's decision binds all rival groups. The freeze of a symbol is an interim measure.
  • Calcutta High Court is hearing the Indian Secular Front's (ISF) challenge to the allotment of the envelope symbol to the Democratic Trinamool Congress (DTC).
  • Mamata Banerjee's faction's disqualification petitions were filed on 8 July 2026. The petitioner is Sovandeb Chattopadhyay, who sought a mandamus to the Speaker.

Data and details

  • Speaker-deadline hearing (Bench led by CJI Surya Kant, with Justice Joymalya Bagchi):
  • The Supreme Court urged the Speaker to conclude disqualification proceedings by 8 October. Sibal noted that three months from the filing of petitions expires on 8 October.
  • Petitions were filed on 8 July 2026 against 10 rival MLAs of the Ritabrata Banerjee faction.
  • The rebels formed a separate front after Trinamool's defeat in this year's Assembly elections, pursuant to an alleged special session on 27 June.
  • Counsel for the Mamata camp: Kapil Sibal, Vivek Tankha, Preetika Dwivedi.
  • The Chief Justice was reluctant to intervene and would only record a "hope" that the Speaker follows Meghachandra.
  • Sibal's "pattern" argument: the Speaker sits on petitions, rebels get an interim EC order, creating "political havoc".
  • Justice Bagchi's remarks: courts too are in breach of timelines, and the Speaker's decision "is not the last word" because it is open to review.
  • EC timeline:
  • The EC's interim order was passed on 17 September. It froze the Trinamool name and symbol ("flowers and grass") for both factions.
  • The EC order is under the Election Symbols (Reservation and Allotment) Order, 1968. It operates during the current bypolls and continues until the final determination of the dispute.
  • Paragraph 39 of the EC's interim order (not of the Symbols Order) says freezing was needed to place "both the rival groups on even keel".
  • The Supreme Court gave both sides four weeks from 28 September to file pleadings before the EC. The EC then has three months to decide.
  • The Court refused EC counsel D.S. Naidu's request for 5–6 months. He had cited the EC's resources being stretched by elections in five States. The Court said to return "in case of extreme exigencies".
  • The Court also refused the Ritabrata faction's (Neeraj Kishan Kaul) request for six weeks instead of four.
  • Sibal and Kalyan Banerjee said Mamata's side filed responses in July and the rival side was yet to file.
  • In the previous hearing the Court had signalled it was unlikely to stay the 17 September interim order.
  • Approximate timeline: four weeks from 28 September ends around 26 October. Three months after that is around late January 2027.
  • Calcutta High Court (Justice Krishna Rao):
  • Question to the EC: any "connivance" with a newly formed outfit in reassigning the envelope symbol? Why was the symbol not given to the ISF, with which it contested the 2026 Bengal polls?
  • EC counsel: symbol allotment is within the Commission's discretion.
  • Petitioner's counsel (Bikash Ranjan Bhattacharya): discretion cannot be "absolute like an autocrat".
  • The court asked how far it can interfere when nominations, scrutiny and withdrawals are complete for the 6 October bypolls. Counsel sought deferment of the bypolls and cited a Supreme Court ruling that courts can facilitate proper conduct of elections.
  • The order was reserved.

Static–dynamic linkage

Two different bodies are deciding two different questions about the same split.

  • The Speaker decides whether the rebel MLAs are disqualified for defection. This is Paragraph 6 of the Tenth Schedule, in a tribunal role.
  • The EC decides which faction is the "real" party and who gets the name and symbol, under Paragraph 15 of the Symbols Order.

The Supreme Court has said these two processes can run concurrently. Delay in one (the Speaker) makes the other (the EC) bite first, which is the "pattern" Sibal highlighted.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Anti-defection law (Tenth Schedule); Parliament/State Legislatures – Speaker's powers and functions; Constitutional bodies – ECI's quasi-judicial role; Separation of powers/dispute redressal.

Background primer

Tenth Schedule (Anti-Defection Law)

What it is:
A part of the Constitution that sets out disqualification of legislators on grounds of defection. The grounds are voluntarily giving up party membership, violating the party whip, an independent member joining a party, and a nominated member joining a party after six months.
Founded:
Added by the 52nd Amendment in 1985. The "Aaya Ram, Gaya Ram" phrase arose in the 1960s after a Haryana MLA switched parties several times in a day.
Why it matters:
Enacted to curb frequent floor-crossing by legislators.

Keisham Meghachandra Singh v. Speaker, Manipur (2020)

Subhash Desai v. Principal Secretary, Governor of Maharashtra (2023)

Election Symbols (Reservation and Allotment) Order, 1968 – Paragraph 15

What it is:
An order that provides for the specification, reservation, choice and allotment of symbols and the recognition of political parties. Reserved symbols go to recognised parties and free symbols to unrecognised parties and independents.

Additional context

  • The EC's interim order barred both factions from using the name "All India Trinamool Congress" and the twin-flower symbol in the Nandigram and Rejinagar bypolls in West Bengal.
  • One faction was allotted the name "Democratic Trinamool Congress" with the envelope symbol. The Mamata Banerjee faction was allotted "Mamata All India Trinamool Congress" with the football-player symbol.
  • The EC said both groups would be treated as recognised parties in West Bengal, Meghalaya and Tripura.
  • Precedent: The EC froze the Lok Janshakti Party's "Bungalow" symbol in 2021 before Bihar bypolls, so neither faction could use it.

Mains dimensions

  • Timeliness vs separation of powers: Meghachandra says three months is an outer limit. Subhash Desai says courts should normally leave disqualification to the Speaker. The Supreme Court here chose a middle path: a "hope" and a nudge, not a mandamus. Sibal's plea for "synchronising" the two judgments identifies a real doctrinal tension.
  • Role of the Speaker: The Speaker belongs to a political party yet acts as a tribunal. The 2020 judgment's idea of an independent tribunal, and the 2nd ARC's idea of the President/Governor deciding on EC advice, remain unadopted.
  • Strategic delay: Delay in the Speaker's tribunal lets the rebel group approach the EC for the party's name and symbol. By the time the Speaker rules, the party's identity may have been decided elsewhere. The Speaker's decision is also "not the last word", as Justice Bagchi noted.
  • EC's interim powers: The freeze is meant to place both factions on an "even keel" for the bypolls. But the Calcutta HC query on the envelope symbol shows allotment from the free-symbol list can itself become a fairness question. The EC's workload (elections in five States) is a real institutional constraint on its three-month timeline.
  • Judicial self-restraint vs electoral integrity: The Calcutta HC itself asked how far it can interfere once the poll process has begun. The Supreme Court had earlier signalled it was unlikely to stay the freeze, and it set time limits for both the Speaker (a "hope" that the Meghachandra rule is followed) and the EC (three months).
  • Way forward: Statutory time limits in the Tenth Schedule; an independent permanent tribunal; clearer allocation between the Speaker's and the EC's roles; criteria for the EC's free-symbol allotments.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "The anti-defection law has been weakened by delays in the Speaker's decisions and by parallel proceedings before the Election Commission. Examine, with reference to recent Supreme Court judgments, whether the adjudication of disqualification should be moved away from the Speaker."

Related topics

  • Kihoto Hollohan (1992); Rajendra Singh Rana (2007); Nabam Rebia (2016)
  • Paragraph 4 (merger) of the Tenth Schedule; 91st Amendment, 2003
  • Article 324 and the EC's quasi-judicial functions; Sadiq Ali v. ECI (1971)
  • Article 142 and judicial directions to constitutional functionaries

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 29 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs