BrainParrot

Wangchuk seeks higher compensation for families of 2025 Leh protest victims

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 28 September 2026

Summary

  • On Sunday, activist Sonam Wangchuk, who campaigns for stronger constitutional safeguards for Ladakh, demanded that the findings of the judicial inquiry into the September 2025 Leh violence be made public. The violence left four dead and about 80 injured.
  • He also called the ₹15 lakh compensation announced by the Ladakh administration inadequate. He wants parity with the ₹1 crore assured to families affected by the NEET paper leak.
  • He questioned the cases against 87 locals.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: Sixth Schedule demand, UT governance, preventive detention, accountability for use of force

Key facts for Prelims

  • Art. 244(1): Fifth Schedule (Scheduled Areas in States other than Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura, Mizoram). Art. 244(2) with Art. 275(1): Sixth Schedule.
  • Sixth Schedule: ADCs and Regional Councils; max 30 members (up to 4 nominated); Governor's assent to council laws; Governor can create, alter or rename autonomous districts.
  • NSA, 1980: preventive detention; max 12 months; Art. 22(3)(b) permits it; Art. 22(4) requires an Advisory Board beyond three months; Art. 22(5) gives a right to representation. The 44th Amendment's reduction of that period to two months has not been brought into force.
  • Ladakh became a Union Territory without a legislature after Art. 370 was abrogated in 2019 (as the Statehood demand context).
  • Judicial inquiry in news: led by a former Supreme Court judge, constituted by the MHA.

Data and details

  • September 24, 2025 Leh violence: four civilians killed in alleged firing by security forces during an agitation for Statehood and Sixth Schedule inclusion; about 80 injured (per the article).
  • Compensation: ₹15 lakh per victim family announced by the Ladakh administration. Wangchuk compares it with the ₹1 crore assured to families affected by the NEET paper leak.
  • Cases filed against 87 locals in connection with the violence.
  • Wangchuk's questions: who ordered the firing; whether all prescribed crowd-control stages were exhausted before live ammunition; why people were hit in vital parts of the body.
  • His principle: those who exercised extraordinary powers must carry extraordinary responsibility.
  • He says Ladakh is "almost a year later" still waiting for the findings.
  • He was arrested under the NSA on September 27, per the article.

Static–dynamic linkage

Ladakh's demand for Statehood and Sixth Schedule status is a demand for constitutional self-rule. It would be a District-Council model of tribal autonomy, in a Union Territory administered by the Centre. The violence raises the usual accountability questions after loss of life in policing:

  • Who ordered the firing?
  • Were graded crowd-control steps exhausted before lethal force?
  • When do inquiry findings become public?

The NSA is a preventive detention statute. Preventive detention is the exception to ordinary arrest safeguards, which is why its use against protest leaders is contentious.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Scheduled and Tribal Areas (Art. 244, Fifth/Sixth Schedules); Union Territories; fundamental rights and preventive detention (Art. 22); GS3 – Internal security: policing of protests, use of force.

Background primer

Sixth Schedule (Art. 244(2) and Art. 275(1))

What it is:
Provisions creating Autonomous District Councils (ADCs) and Regional Councils in specified tribal areas, which function as mini-legislatures and local governments.
Founded:
Part of the original Constitution (passed by the Constituent Assembly in 1949) to protect tribal land, culture and self-governance. This reflects the Constituent Assembly's differentiated approach: the Fifth Schedule for tribal areas in most States, the Sixth for specified north-eastern areas.

National Security Act, 1980 (NSA)

What it is:
A law empowering the government to detain a person it believes is a threat to national security or public order. The detention is preventive, not punitive.
Founded:
Enacted in 1980 as a preventive detention law under the constitutional permission in Art. 22(3)(b).

Additional context

  • The inquiry commission:
    • The MHA notified a judicial inquiry on 17 October 2025 into the circumstances leading to the law-and-order situation, the police action and the deaths of four individuals.
    • It is chaired by Dr Justice B.S. Chauhan, former Supreme Court judge.
    • It commenced proceedings on 27 October 2025.
    • On the Leh Apex Body's representation, a local officer, Rigzin Spalgon, was added as Joint Secretary.
    • Public evidence was invited until 28 November 2025.
    • A published report or a government response to the findings is not confirmed from a trusted source.
  • Wangchuk's detention:
    • The MHA decided on 14 March 2026 to revoke his NSA detention with immediate effect (PIB release).
  • Who is demanding what:
    • The September 2025 protests demanded statehood and extension of Sixth Schedule protections.
    • The Leh Apex Body (LAB) and the Kargil Democratic Alliance (KDA) were formed to represent regional interests.
    • Roughly 90% of Ladakh's population is tribal (per UPSC explainers).
    • On 17 October 2025, the Ladakh Chief Secretary said the Government of India would continue dialogue with the High-Powered Committee (HPC).
  • Why Sixth Schedule extension is difficult:
    • One explainer notes that Ladakh's two Hill Councils (Leh and Kargil) are not under the Sixth Schedule, and that no region outside the North-East had been included.
    • The Constitution's text ties the Sixth Schedule to the four north-eastern States.

Mains dimensions

  • Accountability for use of force: The unanswered "who ordered the firing" and "were graded steps exhausted" questions go to the principles of necessity, proportionality and graded response in public-order policing.
  • Judicial inquiries serve transparency only if findings are published and acted on. Wangchuk says that almost a year on, Ladakh is still waiting for the findings.
  • Compensation: Parity with the ₹1 crore NEET assurance raises the question of whether ex gratia amounts follow any consistent rule or are ad hoc.
  • It also raises whether compensation can substitute for accountability.
  • Preventive detention and dissent: The NSA detention of a protest leader (later revoked by the MHA) tests the line between public order and the right to protest. Its safeguards are thin: no lawyer before the Advisory Board, and withholding of facts is permitted.
  • Prosecution of 87 locals adds to the grievance.
  • Federal/autonomy question: The Sixth Schedule demand reflects the fear of land and identity loss in a UT with no legislature.
  • Alternatives include Art. 371-type protections or a stronger Hill Council framework, since extension of the Sixth Schedule beyond the North-East is legally and politically hard.
  • Strategic sensitivity: Ladakh is a border region, so unrest has security and development implications. Sustained dialogue through the High-Powered Committee is the policy route.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "Recurring unrest in Ladakh reflects the gap between constitutional safeguards and the aspirations of newly created Union Territories. Discuss the demand for Sixth Schedule status and the accountability mechanisms required after violent law-and-order incidents."

Related topics

  • Fifth vs Sixth Schedule; Art. 371 special provisions; Scheduled Tribes and Forest Rights
  • Art. 22 and preventive detention (Art. 22(3)(b), 22(4)–(5)); habeas corpus (Arts 32, 226)
  • Commissions of Inquiry Act, 1952 (inquiry reports and tabling)
  • Union Territories (Art. 239 and the J&K Reorganisation Act, 2019)
  • Policing of protests, the right to assemble peacefully (Art. 19(1)(b)) and reasonable restrictions

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 28 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs