BrainParrot

The right to VOTE, on trial

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 27 September 2026

Summary

  • In Karnataka, the last phase of the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) has produced notices for 43.81 lakh people, 24.05 lakh of them in Bengaluru. Voters, especially poor and daily-wage workers, report document burdens, bulk notices and deletions with no appeal.
  • On Saturday the Election Commission, after a full-Commission meeting, announced "damage control" steps: no physical hearings for unmapped or discrepancy cases, extended claims deadlines for Delhi and Maharashtra, and limits on the Form 6 declaration. This came amid reports of a rift among the Commissioners.
  • In Bengaluru, Assistant Electoral Registration Officers (AEROs) say they are being pressed orally to demand "citizenship certificates".

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: Electoral rolls, right to vote, Election Commission, governance and exclusion

Key facts for Prelims

  • Art. 324: ECI's superintendence of rolls and elections. Art. 326: adult suffrage for citizens aged 18 and above, unless disqualified by law. Sections 16 and 19, RP Act, 1950: non-citizens are excluded from the roll; registration requires a person to be 18+ and ordinarily resident in the constituency.
  • Form 6 = new-voter registration (Registration of Electors Rules, 1960). The ECI says the declaration form attached to Form 6 under SIR was upheld by the Supreme Court. Outside SIR, the forms prescribed by the Rules are used.
  • Officers: BLO (polling-station level), ERO and AERO (constituency/tehsil level), District Election Officer, Chief Electoral Officer; the ERO decides on inclusion and exclusion.
  • ASDDO = Absent, Shifted, Duplicate, Dead and Others. In Karnataka, names in this list were deleted without a formal appeal. The only remedy is Form 6 as a "new voter".
  • Two groups noticed: those not linkable to the 2002 rolls ("unmapped with last SIR") and those flagged for "logical discrepancies", which cover nine categories such as name or parent-name differences and implausible age gaps between elector and parent or grandparent.
  • ECINet is the digital platform on which BLOs and EROs upload documents and decisions.
  • Precedent: J.M. Lyngdoh (CEC, 2003) ordered decentralised social audits of rolls through gram sabhas and ward sabhas in five States.
  • Citizenship certificate by naturalisation: requires a cumulative residence of 12 years, as the AEROs pointed out. A citizenship certificate is not in the ECI's indicative document list.
  • EC's Saturday decisions: the Form 6 declaration is mandatory only during the current SIR. The Delhi claims and objections deadline moved to Oct 30, and Maharashtra's to Oct 12.

Data and details

  • Karnataka notices: 43.81 lakh people, 24.05 lakh of them in Bengaluru. SIR has already been completed in 20 States and UTs.
  • Karnataka deletions: Bengaluru shows 45% deletion against 13% overall in districts. Statewide, 36 polling stations saw 70–90% deletions, and two (in Sarvagnanagar AC, BBMP North, and Kodagu) saw over 90%. More than 20 of the 36 are in Bengaluru Urban.
  • Reasons for deletion: "shifted" or "absent" make up at least 90% of deletions in most constituencies, which sits oddly beside migration being a reason SIR was launched. Members of one family were sometimes marked shifted while others received forms.
  • Claims versus deletions: 6.96 lakh Form-6 applications as on Sept 20, against 80.62 lakh names deleted as shifted or absent. Fewer than one in 10 deleted names applied, though the figure includes new voters. The claims window ended Sept 23.
  • Third-party exposure: 5.54 crore electors' data was searchable outside the CEO's platform. The CEO took no action beyond advising electors to use the official site.
  • Notice logistics: the notice list went online on Sept 6 after public pressure, with no communication on where to check it. The CEO said on Sept 18 that 79.79% of notices were "delivered". Residents said BLOs called them to hearing venues and asked them to sign that the notice had been delivered.
  • Language: notices were Kannada-only despite an assurance that Bengaluru notices would be bilingual.
  • Cost and documents: indicative-list documents cost at least ₹600–700 each. Manjunath paid ₹1,250 for a permanent-residence certificate that is still unprocessed, and later learned his name was not on the official list.
  • Vulnerable groups: in Byatarayanapura, 16 of 21 domestic workers interviewed were marked "unmapped with last SIR". Lakshmi Devi's family of six: four notices. The family has been in Chikka Banasawadi since 1961 and holds only Aadhaar and ration cards. A 78-year-old retired officer was asked for grandparents' documents.
  • Bulk generation: whole families or apartment blocks were flagged, for example in Bapuji Nagar and Peenya. Officials acknowledged at least three correctly filled cases in Byatarayanapura. "VIP voters" were promised direct inclusion, "noting their contributions".
  • Rajasthan precedent: the 2003 Lyngdoh social audit led to more than seven lakh corrections in Rajasthan alone. The 2023 summary-revision manual required BLOs to read out draft rolls at gram sabha or ward committee meetings, while the SIR 2025 manual does not mention reading out rolls.
  • BLO strain: BLOs have worked under extreme conditions since May. They were told of the notice-phase role less than a week before it began, faced ECINet transliteration glitches, and could not correct information before bulk notice generation. Education Department BLOs sought exemptions. In hearings, Aadhaar and ration cards were accepted, but BLOs said these are not indicative documents and they do not know their fate in the final rolls. CEO V. Anbu Kumar was unavailable for comment.
  • Bengaluru AEROs: told orally in weekly meetings (latest Sept 25) to identify suspected Nepali or Bangladeshi nationals and demand citizenship certificates even from Indian passport holders. Most AEROs said they were bypassing this. They fear this would profile citizens and force them to declare citizens without such certificates "ineligible".
  • EC's course correction (Saturday's press note):
  • BLOs will visit homes to collect documents and upload them on ECINet for ERO decisions. People need not be called to hearings.
  • Hearings are held only in exceptional circumstances, preferably online, and any adult family member may attend on the elector's behalf.
  • Any left-out person, including young voters, may apply to the ERO, and a special enrolment drive was announced.
  • A committee led by a Senior Deputy Election Commissioner with an independent IIT/IIIT expert will review ECINet for compliance with the Acts and Rules.
  • Field officers have role-based access as per their statutory powers, with more flexibility if needed.
  • Commission meetings will have advance agendas and minutes, and foreign trips of officers need Commission approval.
  • The press note carried a photo of all three Commissioners and said it had the full Commission's approval.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Universal adult suffrage and eligibility are constitutional, under Art. 326. The ECI's duty is to keep rolls both complete and clean.
  • Exclusion error (a genuine voter deleted) and inclusion error (an ineligible name kept) are different harms. In an intensive revision, who bears the burden of proof and who can appeal become the central questions.
  • Procedural fairness matters here: notice, a hearing, a reasoned decision and a remedy. These are the elements that mass bulk notices and ASDDO deletions are said to lack.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 — Polity: Representation of the People Act, 1950 (preparation and revision of rolls); Election Commission (Art. 324); universal adult suffrage (Art. 326); GS2 — Governance: transparency, accountability, citizen-centric administration

Background primer

Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls

What it is:
a house-to-house re-enumeration drive by the ECI to build fresh rolls by removing deceased, shifted, duplicate and ineligible voters.
Mandate:
enumeration forms are collected and a draft roll published. Notices go to electors who could not be matched with the last SIR. EROs/AEROs hear them and decide inclusion for the final roll. New voters apply in Form 6 with a declaration.
Why it matters:
"pure" rolls: no eligible citizen left out and no ineligible person included.

Form 6 and the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960

Additional context

  • The term "Special Intensive Revision" does not appear in the RP Act, 1950 or the 1960 Rules. The ECI relies on Section 21(3) (special revision, with reasons recorded) and Art. 324. Petitioners argued this left the exercise resting on administrative discretion.
  • The Supreme Court has since upheld the SIR's validity under Art. 324 read with Section 21(3). It held that the ECI may examine citizenship only for the limited purpose of deciding who is on the roll, and that deletion on this ground is not a declaration of non-citizenship. It also treated the inclusion of Aadhaar as a valid document as a key safeguard.
  • This is background for the Bengaluru report that AEROs were told to seek "citizenship certificates".

Mains dimensions

  • Exclusion versus purity: the stated aim is cleaner rolls, but the process tests whether the burden of proof sits fairly. Eligible voters are being asked for decades-old or ancestral documents while many lack paper trails (slum dwellers, women, daily-wage workers, senior citizens).
  • Cost of franchise: documents cost ₹600–1,250. Lost wages, travel and repeated visits fall on the poor, and many documents are not in the elector's own name (women). The result is a de facto barrier to a constitutional right.
  • Due process gaps:
  • Bulk, software-generated notices, with no BLO verification before generation.
  • Notice lists not communicated, and notices in one language.
  • Deletion as ASDDO before verification, with no appeal.
  • Unequal treatment of "VIP voters" against common citizens.
  • Data governance: 5.54 crore electors' data became searchable on unofficial sites, with no action taken. This links to privacy concerns raised by the Puttaswamy privacy framework.
  • Community-level verification as a remedy: the Lyngdoh gram-sabha audits (Rajasthan: over seven lakh corrections) and the 2023 reading-out requirement show a tested model that the SIR manual omits.
  • Technology and centralisation: ECINet transliteration glitches, BLOs' inability to verify or correct data before bulk notices were generated, and field officers' reported lack of access to the portal show how technology design can override statutory discretion.
  • Citizenship profiling: oral instructions to demand citizenship certificates, which are not in the indicative list, risk profiling and exceed the role of rolls verification. AEROs themselves objected.
  • EC's response: shifting to home collection, online hearings and proxy attendance reduces burdens. But the reforms came after public pressure and internal dissent, and many deletions already stand. The low Form-6 uptake (under 1 in 10) suggests many may stay off rolls unless outreach is active.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls seeks to ensure that no eligible citizen is left out and no ineligible person is included. Examine how the process, as seen in Karnataka, has affected marginalised voters, and suggest institutional safeguards to balance roll purity with universal franchise."

Related topics

  • Representation of the People Act, 1950: Sections on preparation and revision of rolls and qualifications for registration; Registration of Electors Rules, 1960
  • Art. 326 and the history of universal adult suffrage; NOTA/EPIC and Aadhaar–voter ID linking debates
  • Right to privacy (Puttaswamy) and personal data protection
  • Natural justice (audi alteram partem) in administrative action
  • Dissent within the Election Commission (see the companion note on the CEC and ECs)
  • Gram sabha and social audit as accountability tools

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 27 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs