A.P. govt. refuses to defend Centre’s changes to trans rights law in court
Source: The Hindu, 27 September 2026
Summary
- In an affidavit filed in August, Andhra Pradesh (ruled by the TDP, an NDA/BJP ally) told the Supreme Court that it played no role in enacting the 2026 amendments to the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act. It said their constitutional validity is "primarily a matter for the Union of India".
- At least a dozen petitions challenge the amendments. The Centre has yet to respond. Uttarakhand (BJP-ruled) has defended the law.
- The split between NDA-ruled States shows how contested the amendment is.
Key facts for Prelims
- Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019; amended in 2026 (the amendment removes the right to "self-perceived gender identity" and limits the definition of "transgender person" to physiological characteristics, as reported).
- NALSA v. Union of India (2014): landmark Supreme Court judgment recognising the "third gender" and the right to self-determination of gender identity.
- National Council for Transgender Persons: its members resigned in protest over the amendments.
- Section 4(2) of the 2019 Act is the self-perceived gender identity provision.
- District Magistrate issues the certificate of identity.
- Andhra Pradesh and Uttarakhand have filed affidavits taking opposite positions. The matter is before the Supreme Court as a batch of at least a dozen petitions.
Data and details
- Andhra Pradesh figures (affidavit): 3,750 applications for transgender identity cards. 3,233 certificates issued, 403 "filtered" and 114 pending.
- A.P.'s position: it has "not taken any independent action that is discriminatory towards transgender persons". It says the Act's validity is for the Union.
- Uttarakhand's position: matters concerning transgender rights and healthcare are "influenced by social norms and existing systems". The amended law's operation in the State caused no "denial, dilution, erosion or abridgement" of rights, and identification, certification, welfare and rehabilitation continue.
- Parliamentary debate: the Bill was discussed in the Lok Sabha on March 24. TDP MP Byreddy Shabari supported it, citing alleged complaints that people were falsely adopting transgender identity to beg at traffic signals.
- Government argument: retaining self-determination would lead to false claims to welfare benefits. Opposition MPs called removal "an attack on Constitutional morality" and on dignity.
- Aftermath: widespread protests, resignations from the National Council for Transgender Persons, yet Parliament passed the Bill and the government notified it.
- The Centre has not yet responded to the challenges.
Static–dynamic linkage
- The conflict is between statutory rights and a judicially recognised constitutional right. NALSA (2014) treated gender self-identification as part of dignity and personal liberty. The amendments narrow the statute and replace self-perception with a certification regime.
- Policy argument for the change: self-declaration may be misused to claim welfare benefits. Counter-argument: the removal of self-determination contradicts the NALSA principle and "constitutional morality".
- Federal dimension: States implement the Act (identification, certification, welfare) and have filed affidavits in the Court, so their stance matters.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 — Polity: Fundamental Rights (Arts. 14, 15, 16, 19, 21), judicial review, Centre–State relations; GS2 — Social Justice: welfare mechanisms and laws for vulnerable sections
Background primer
Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019
- What it is:
- a law to protect transgender persons' rights and welfare. Parliament passed it in 2019.
Additional context
-
PRS notes that the 2026 Bill removes the right to self-perceived identity. Its Statement of Objects says the existing definition is vague, which makes beneficiaries hard to identify.
-
Under the amendment, the District Magistrate issues the certificate after examining the recommendation of a medical board.
-
The Bill drops trans-men, trans-women and genderqueer from the definition and adds "eunuch" and persons forced to assume a transgender identity through mutilation or similar procedures.
-
In Jane Kaushik v. Union of India (October 2025), the Supreme Court criticised the Union and States for poor implementation of the 2019 Act. It noted that its earlier 2022 direction (Shanavi Ponnusamy) to devise an employment policy framework in consultation with the National Council for Transgender Persons had not been followed, and that the Union's stance was that no policy was needed. This shows the Council, whose members the article says resigned, has a live policy role.
Mains dimensions
- Rights framework:
- NALSA treats self-identification as intrinsic to Articles 14, 15, 16, 19 and 21.
- The amendment shifts from self-determined to State-certified identity. Critics say a medical-board gate conflicts with NALSA's rejection of biological tests as the sole basis.
- The government's counter is a verifiable beneficiary framework and stronger penalties on coercion. Less restrictive safeguards could meet that aim.
- Federalism and political signalling: A.P. (a BJP ally) declined to defend the Centre's law. This is an unusual cooperative-federalism moment where State and Centre positions diverge. A.P.'s TDP MP had supported the Bill in the Lok Sabha, so the affidavit reflects distance, not formal opposition. Uttarakhand's defence shows the split inside the NDA.
- Implementation reality: A.P.'s numbers show 403 applications "filtered" and 114 pending, which signals how the certification process actually works at the district level.
- Institutional voice: resignations of National Council members show that the statutory consultative body was not aligned with the amendment. This is a governance and consultation question.
- Judicial review: the Court will test the amendment against NALSA and Article 21, and this will likely depend on how it treats "misuse" as a justification for narrowing rights.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "Self-determination of gender identity has been recognised as part of the right to dignity and personal liberty. Critically evaluate the 2026 amendments to the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019 in light of the NALSA judgment and the concerns of misuse of welfare benefits."
Related topics
- NALSA (2014); Navtej Singh Johar (2018); Puttaswamy (privacy and dignity)
- Articles 14, 15, 16, 19, 21; "constitutional morality"
- Centre–State relations and the role of States as litigants before the Supreme Court
- Welfare delivery and targeting; DBT and identity certification
- National Council for Transgender Persons and statutory advisory bodies
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 27 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs