BrainParrot

Lawyer group calls for fresh hearing in the Noida DM case

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 26 September 2026

Summary

  • A group of advocates, the Lawyers Association for Constitution, issued a statement. It seeks a recall of the Supreme Court's 23 Sept interim order in the appeal of Noida DM Medha Roopam, who is CEC Gyanesh Kumar's daughter. It also seeks a fresh hearing of the petitions challenging the 2023 CEC/EC appointment law.
  • Both matters, it says, should be heard by a Bench that excludes Justice Satish Chandra Sharma.
  • Separately, a petition in the Supreme Court seeks a Judicial Inquiry Commission or SIT, headed by a retired Supreme Court judge, to probe allegations against the CEC. It also seeks an audit of the Election Commission's databases.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: Judiciary (Bench composition, recusal, Constitution Bench), Election Commission independence

Key facts for Prelims

  • Article 324(2): the CEC and ECs are appointed by the President, subject to a parliamentary law.
  • 2023 Act: Selection Committee = PM, Leader of Opposition (Lok Sabha) and a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the PM. It replaced the CJI-in-panel arrangement of Anoop Baranwal.
  • Search Committee (Law Minister plus two Secretary-rank officers) proposes five names.
  • Term of CEC/EC: six years or age 65, whichever is earlier; no re-appointment.
  • CEC removal: like a Supreme Court judge (Art. 324(5) first proviso, Section 11(2) of the 2023 Act).
  • Article 145(3): minimum five judges for substantial constitutional questions.
  • Article 32: remedy for enforcement of fundamental rights; the petitions invoke Article 14 with Article 324.
  • Section 32, RP Act 1950: penalty for breach of official duty in connection with preparation of rolls (the plea cites it). Section 16 of the 2023 Act is the protection provision the plea contends fails if the nexus breaks.
  • Ranjit Thakur (1987): reasonableness of apprehension of bias.
  • Anoop Baranwal: a pro tem Selection Committee under Art. 142 until Parliament legislates.

Data and details

  • Issued Friday by the Lawyers Association for Constitution and circulated online by Supreme Court advocate Subhash Chandran K.R.
  • The 23 Sept interim order in Roopam's appeal came from the Division Bench led by Justice Sharma.
  • On the same day, Justice Sharma disagreed with Justice Dipankar Datta on referral. Justice Datta rejected a reference and would hear the merits of the challenge to the 2023 law. Justice Sharma favoured a reference to a five-judge Bench. The matter is now pending before the CJI.
  • Concerns come "from public reports":
  • "Improper listing" before a Bench that did not hold the roster for petitions linked to habeas corpus pleas.
  • Justice Sharma's son is reportedly empanelled as standing counsel for the ECI in the Madhya Pradesh High Court.
  • The group says it does not know whether this was brought to the parties' notice. It says it is "not on the merits" but on how the circumstances may appear to the public, and it invokes the fair-minded, informed observer test.
  • Filed Friday by advocate Shailendra Mani Tripathi, represented by advocate Chand Qureshi, after The Indian Express exposé.
  • It seeks a Judicial Inquiry Commission or SIT headed by a retired Supreme Court judge, with an end-to-end audit of EC databases. It also seeks a probe into the institutional circumstances in which 13 crore names were deleted across 30 States/UTs under the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls.
  • It argues the CEC would be "divested" of immunity and remain accountable as an "ordinary accused", subject to police investigation, evidence gathering and regular trial.
  • Its claim is that the allegations lack a "reasonable nexus" with official functions and include electoral-roll tampering.
  • It says the allegations are cognisable under Section 32 RP Act 1950 and the BNS, and that Section 16 of the 2023 Act protection is ineffective once the nexus breaks.
  • These are the petitioner's contentions, not findings.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Bias test. Natural justice requires that no one be a judge in their own cause (nemo judex in causa sua) and that justice be seen to be done. Courts ask whether a reasonable, informed observer would apprehend bias, not whether bias in fact occurred. The lawyers' statement uses this framing and says it is not on the merits.
  • Larger Bench. Substantial questions on interpreting the Constitution go to at least five judges under Article 145(3). When two judges split, the matter goes to the Chief Justice, who is master of the roster, to constitute a larger Bench.
  • CEC accountability. The CEC's tenure is protected by Article 324(5) and by the 2023 Act. The plea tests how far this immunity covers acts that allegedly have no nexus with official duties.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Judiciary (structure, Bench constitution, Article 145(3) reference to a Constitution Bench, principles of natural justice); Constitutional bodies (Art. 324).

Background primer

Chief Election Commissioner & other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023

What it is:
An Act to regulate appointment, conditions of service and term of office of the CEC and ECs, and the Commission's procedure for transacting business.
Founded:
Act No. 49 of 2023, assented on 28 December 2023. It replaced the Election Commission (Conditions of Service of Election Commissioners and Transaction of Business) Act, 1991. It followed the Supreme Court's March 2023 ruling. The Court held that the Executive alone should not appoint them and laid down a Selection Committee process to hold until Parliament legislated.

Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India (2023)

What it is:
A Constitution Bench ruling on appointing the CEC and ECs.
Why it matters:
Independence of the ECI from exclusive executive control.

Recusal / bias doctrine

What it is:
A judge withdraws where there is a conflict of interest or a reasonable apprehension of bias.
Why it matters:
Public confidence, because justice should not only be done but seen to be done.

Additional context

  • The Supreme Court's 23 September 2026 judgment text records petitions under Article 32 that challenge provisions of the 2023 Act as ultra vires Article 14 read with Article 324.
  • The same text records reasoning that the Baranwal directions were interim until Parliament legislated, and that the 2023 Act replaced a judicial interim arrangement with a legislative rule.
  • A UPSC explainer describes the 23 September outcome as a split verdict by a two-judge Bench on whether a five-judge Bench is needed.
  • Gyanesh Kumar was the first CEC appointed under the 2023 Act. He and S.S. Sandhu were appointed ECs under it in March 2024.
  • A UPSC-coaching profile describes Medha Roopam as a 2014-batch IAS officer and Gautam Buddh Nagar DM, and her father Gyanesh Kumar as a retired Kerala-cadre IAS officer.
  • The subject matter of the Noida DM appeal and its link to habeas corpus listing is not confirmed from a trusted source.

Mains dimensions

  • Perception vs proof: The lawyers' group rests on the apprehension-of-bias test and stresses that it is not on the merits. It relies on "public reports" and asks whether parties were told.
  • Roster discipline: The "improper listing" point goes to the CJI's authority over allocation of matters. Whether a Bench holds the relevant roster is a procedural-legitimacy issue.
  • Split verdict: Justices Sharma and Datta differ on referral to a five-judge Bench. A pending reference delays settling the legality of the 2023 selection mechanism while the CEC is itself the subject of allegations.
  • Independence of the ECI: The Baranwal rationale of insulating the ECI from exclusive executive control now meets a statute where the executive has two of three Selection Committee votes. It is also the Act that appointed the current CEC.
  • Immunity and accountability: The plea asks whether protection for official acts covers alleged malpractice with no "reasonable nexus" to official functions, and whether the Parliament-led removal route is the only accountability route.
  • Scale of SIR: The 13 crore deletions across 30 States/UTs, as the plea claims, tie this litigation to the SIR controversy.
  • Way forward: Early settlement of the reference, transparent disclosure of conflicts, and a clear protocol for matters involving constitutional functionaries' relatives.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "Examine whether the Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023 adequately secures the independence of the Election Commission in the light of the Anoop Baranwal judgment."

Related topics

  • Article 324(5) and the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968
  • Anoop Baranwal and Article 142; the "constitutional vacuum" doctrine
  • Basic structure: free and fair elections
  • CJI as master of the roster; Article 145(3) and Constitution Benches
  • Principles of natural justice (nemo judex, audi alteram partem)
  • Judicial accountability and recusal
  • The Form 6 / SIR controversy (see the lead SIR note)

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 26 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs