CJP seeks resignation of CEC, warns of nationwide agitation
Source: The Hindu, 25 September 2026
Summary
- A report by The Indian Express said the two other Election Commissioners, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, recorded written objections at least 14 times between October 2025 and August 2026 to SIR-related decisions. Many of those decisions, they said, were taken without their knowledge.
- The report set off a day of reactions. The Cockroach Janta Party (CJP) gave CEC Gyanesh Kumar a 48-hour ultimatum to resign. Rahul Gandhi and Priyanka Gandhi Vadra demanded his ouster or prosecution. Five Left parties announced a week-long protest. An advocate sought to initiate contempt action. The Opposition prepared a fresh removal notice in Parliament. The BJP rejected the allegations as baseless.
- Alongside this, the Election Commission's (EC) expanded "logical discrepancy" categories in the third phase of SIR left many electors, including some wrongly flagged, on discrepancy lists.
Key facts for Prelims
- Art. 324: Election Commission's superintendence, direction and control of elections to Parliament, State Legislatures, and the offices of President and Vice-President.
- Art. 324(5): the CEC is removable only "in like manner and on like grounds" as a Supreme Court judge (cf. Art. 124(4)); other ECs only on the CEC's recommendation.
- CEC and Other ECs (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023: replaced the 1991 Act; Selection Committee = PM, LoP (Lok Sabha), Union Cabinet Minister; tenure 6 years or age 65; business as far as possible by unanimity, differences by majority.
- The 2023 Act's selection panel omits the CJI, who was in the panel proposed by the Supreme Court (Anoop Baranwal).
- Section 21(3) of the RP Act, 1950: special revision of electoral rolls "in such manner as it may think fit"; Art. 326: adult suffrage; Registration of Electors Rules, 1960.
- ERONet (Electoral Roll Officers' Network): the centralised platform used for roll management; flagged discrepancies via AI-based "progeny-mapping".
- Electoral Registration Officer (ERO) and Booth Level Officer (BLO): the field functionaries of roll revision.
- Criminal contempt of the Supreme Court by a private person requires the consent of the Attorney-General (Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, s.15; Art. 129 makes the Supreme Court a court of record).
- INDIA bloc = Indian National Developmental, Inclusive Alliance.
Data and details
- Two ECs, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, objected on record at least 14 times between October 2025 and August 2026 (about 10 months). Many decisions were taken without their knowledge.
- Advocate Brajesh Singh cited this as a "complete breakdown of multi-member consensus" and "deep structural subversions". He argued it violated precedents requiring the EC to function through institutional consensus, and that the CEC is only primus inter pares.
- The two ECs also flagged that ERONet had become increasingly centralised, and that EROs said they often could not access the platform.
- 48-hour ultimatum for resignation; threat of a nationwide agitation and "Jantar Mantar 2.0". Other speakers: founder Abhijeet Dipke, co-convenors Saurav Das (running the "School Theek Karo" campaign) and Ashutosh Ranka.
- Demands: resignation; criminal proceedings against the CEC; an independent inquiry commission on all SIR proceedings so far; the Supreme Court to seize all SIR decision-making files before the EC destroys them; halt all upcoming elections; restore the January 2025 pre-SIR rolls in all States; repeal the 2023 Act and redraw it with civil society and an independent selection process.
- Dipke's argument: the ruling party has won in more States than at the peak of the "Modi wave"; since Kumar became CEC, "the government decides who may vote". He also urged Opposition parties not to "participate in the election and speak against rigging" at once.
- Das said the two ECs "called this illegal", yet the EC kept carrying out the actions for months.
- Rahul Gandhi (LoP, Lok Sabha) called the PM, Home Minister and CEC "deshdrohis", said the CEC should turn approver in the alleged "vote chori", and said he was "100% certain" that the 2024 Lok Sabha and Assembly elections were rigged.
- He appreciated the ECs' dissent but said it began only after his press conferences. He said India has never had a "fundamentally broken" election system since 1947. He told The Hindu that a BJP sweep nationally "will not be believed".
- The Congress Working Committee meets on 29 September to decide the way forward.
- Priyanka Gandhi Vadra (Wayanad MP) demanded the CEC be prosecuted for treason for "intentionally allowing" an unfair election, by deleting around 13 crore voters from the rolls. She asked why the CEC should have legal protection against criminal law.
- Five Left parties issued a joint statement after an impromptu meeting of M.A. Baby (CPI(M)), D. Raja (CPI) and Dipankar Bhattacharya (CPI(ML) Liberation) at CPI(M) headquarters. The other signatories are the Revolutionary Socialist Party and the All India Forward Bloc.
- Week-long nationwide protest from 26 September to 2 October. Demands: oust the CEC; halt SIR; restore votes of those wrongly excluded; reinstate EC's "independent and democratic functioning"; replace the appointment system with the Supreme Court-proposed committee of PM, LoP and CJI.
- They said the report exposed the hollowness of claims that SIR and roll management are transparent and decentralised.
- First notice, 12 March: signed by 63 Rajya Sabha and 130 Lok Sabha MPs, with seven charges, including that the appointment was "tainted" (the selection law being under challenge in the Supreme Court) and that his previous postings showed "deep executive embeddedness". Dismissed on 7 April.
- Second notice, 24 April, in Rajya Sabha: signed by 73 Opposition members; 13 pages, nine charges, including "disenfranchisement" in West Bengal and Uttar Pradesh, "illegal abuse" of power and "asymmetrical enforcement" of the Model Code of Conduct. It is still pending with Chairman C.P. Radhakrishnan.
- A fresh notice with "more specific charges" will be moved in both Houses (Jairam Ramesh). An INDIA bloc meeting is being considered. The bloc is anxious not to look like a latecomer after the CJP's ultimatum. Derek O'Brien (TMC, which helped draft the two earlier notices) urged united and swift action.
- Called Rahul Gandhi a "master of deception" with "zero political knowledge" and said the allegations lack credible evidence.
- Argued that anti-incumbency hits the Congress: it has not won Tamil Nadu since 1967 or West Bengal since 1977 (Left rule for 34 years, then Mamata Banerjee for three terms). He cited Madhya Pradesh and Keralam.
- Said elections are now more transparent: CCTV monitoring, central paramilitary forces instead of local police, an independent media and judiciary.
- Alleged the Gandhis win their seats only with allies' help: Wayanad via the Muslim League, Amethi and Rae Bareli via the Samajwadi Party.
- Questioned whether there is any evidence that an EC decision was not unanimous. Said SIR is authorised under the RP Act and needed for verification, especially in areas hit by "demographic change".
- Up to 11 categories, applied across States/UTs (Karnataka, Haryana, Delhi, Telangana and others). They expanded from the original four used in West Bengal's SIR.
- Examples: parent–voter age gap under 15 years; voter–grandparent gap under 40 years; more than six siblings linked to one parent; spelling or name variations of a parent between rolls; changed relative mapping (father to mother); marital mapping mismatch (father in the old roll, husband in the current roll, without cross-referencing); implausible age progression across revisions; and a minimum nine-month gap between siblings.
- Illustration: a Pitampura (Delhi) family's 30-year-old twins were flagged under the nine-month rule.
- Flagging is done by a centralised AI system through ERONet, using "progeny-mapping" (linking a voter to the parent's entry on the base roll).
- Notices issued: about 1.36 crore in West Bengal; 19.33 lakh in Delhi; 20.35 lakh in Karnataka.
- Notably absent: "logical discrepancy" has never been clearly defined in any official communication, neither in the EC's May 2026 notice nor in the original June 2025 SIR order. Its parameters and methodology are not publicly documented.
- Saket Gokhale (former TMC MP, RTI activist) said the EC refused to disclose software details under RTI, citing "commercial confidence" or "trade secret", and called the algorithm opaque.
Static–dynamic linkage
The EC is a constitutional body with the "superintendence, direction and control" of elections (Art. 324). Its independence rests on three things: a collegial, multi-member structure; the CEC's removal protection (like a Supreme Court judge); and a fair appointment process. This news tests all three at once:
- Is the Commission really deciding collegially?
- Can a CEC practically be held to account, given how high the removal bar is?
- Is SIR, a statutory special revision of rolls, being run transparently and without exclusion?
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Constitutional bodies (Election Commission, Art. 324); Representation of the People Acts; electoral reforms; GS2 – Governance: transparency and accountability of regulatory bodies.
Background primer
Election Commission of India (ECI) and the CEC
- What it is:
- A permanent constitutional body under Art. 324. The Commission consists of the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) and such number of other Election Commissioners (ECs) as the President decides.
- Founded:
- Established with the Constitution in 1950. The Commission briefly became multi-member in 1989, the extra posts were abolished in 1990, and the multi-member structure was restored permanently in 1993. The Supreme Court upheld this structure in N. Seshan v. Union of India.
- Why it matters:
- Insulating the poll body from the executive so that elections stay "free and fair", a basic-structure feature of the Constitution.
Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls
- What it is:
- A focused, time-bound house-to-house verification of voters by Booth Level Officers (BLOs) to update and correct the electoral rolls.
- Why it matters:
- Roll accuracy, supporting "one person, one vote". The counter-concern is that wrongful exclusion disenfranchises citizens.
Additional context
-
The Supreme Court (ADR v. ECI) upheld the EC's power to conduct SIR. It held the exercise justified under Art. 324 read with Section 21(3) of the RP Act, 1950. It rejected the argument that special revisions can only be done in isolated constituencies, holding the ECI can scale the exercise statewide or nationwide if systemic inaccuracies require it. It also held that the EC's examination of citizenship does not divest anyone of citizenship claims, which remain for the competent authority under the Citizenship Act.
-
The 2023 selection law has been challenged in the Supreme Court. In Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India the Court had earlier suggested including the Chief Justice of India in the selection panel; the law is under challenge in Jaya Thakur v. Union of India. Critics say replacing the PM–LoP–CJI panel with one of PM, LoP and a Union Minister lets the executive dominate selection.
-
No CEC has so far been removed through the constitutional removal procedure.
-
Notice for removal: A removal notice must be backed by 100 Lok Sabha MPs or 50 Rajya Sabha MPs (the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968 route, which applies "like a Supreme Court judge").
Mains dimensions
- Collegiality vs. unilateralism: 14 recorded objections in 10 months, many on decisions taken "without their knowledge", test the Act's rule of unanimity or majority. Under that rule the CEC cannot override two colleagues, so the question is whether decisions were taken in the Commission's name without consultation. Both sides rest on contested claims: the BJP asks for evidence of any non-unanimous decision, while Rahul Gandhi says the dissent only follows his own disclosures.
- Accountability asymmetry: The CEC's removal bar is deliberately high (a special majority in both Houses on proved misbehaviour or incapacity). The first notice (63 RS + 130 LS signatories) was dismissed on 7 April and the second (73 signatories) is pending. The 2023 Act also gives immunity for official acts. The result is that accountability gets pushed to the street (CJP, Left protests) and to courts (the contempt plea), which have no direct power to remove a CEC.
- Appointment design as the root issue: The CJP wants the 2023 Act repealed and the Left wants the PM–LoP–CJI committee; both seek to restore a judicial voice. The law is under challenge in the Supreme Court. Reforms in this direction would link back to the executive-dominance critique.
- SIR transparency and algorithmic governance: "Logical discrepancies" are undefined in the May 2026 notice and the June 2025 order. They are flagged by an AI system whose logic the EC calls commercially confidential. The rules assume rigid family patterns (a nine-month sibling gap, a 15-year age gap) that fail for twins, adoption, late marriage and remarriage. This puts the burden of proof on citizens, and 1.36 crore (West Bengal), 19.33 lakh (Delhi) and 20.35 lakh (Karnataka) notices show the scale. The principle that wrongful exclusion is worse than wrongful inclusion fits here.
- Right to vote and legitimacy: Art. 326 gives universal adult suffrage. Priyanka Gandhi's figure of about 13 crore deletions and the CJP's demand to restore January 2025 rolls show how SIR has become a legitimacy fight. The Supreme Court has upheld SIR's legality (ADR v. ECI) but with procedural safeguards, so the live dispute is about implementation, not legal power.
- Politicisation vs. evidence: The Congress frames it as "vote chori" and treason; the BJP calls it baseless and cites anti-incumbency. A neutral reading separates (i) documented process concerns (the EC dissent, undefined categories, centralised software) from (ii) larger claims of rigging that need evidence. The CJP's call to halt all elections is also a drastic demand with no constitutional basis, since Art. 324 and Part XV require the EC to conduct elections on schedule.
- Way forward: Publish minutes and records of Commission decisions, or at least dissent notes; define the discrepancy categories in the rules and publish the algorithm's logic, or have it audited independently; give EROs control over final decisions; ensure a hearing before any deletion; reform the appointment process; and set up a statutory framework for SIR instead of executive orders.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The independence of the Election Commission depends as much on its internal collegiality and transparency as on constitutional safeguards for its members. Discuss in the light of the recent controversies over the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls and the office of the Chief Election Commissioner. Suggest reforms."
Related topics
- Art. 324–329 (Part XV: Elections); Art. 124(4) and the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968 (removal procedure)
- Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India (2023) and the 2023 CEC Appointment Act; the 255th Law Commission report on electoral reforms
- Representation of the People Acts, 1950 and 1951; Registration of Electors Rules, 1960; Model Code of Conduct
- Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 (criminal contempt, AG's consent)
- ADR v. ECI (27 May 2026, 2026 INSC 564): Supreme Court's verdict upholding the Bihar SIR (Art. 324 read with Section 21(3) of the RP Act, 1950; proportionality test; Rule 21A safeguards)
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 25 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs