BrainParrot

Wangchuk slams delay in making judicial panel report public

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 23 September 2026

Summary

  • Sonam Wangchuk said civil society groups would form a "people's tribunal" to probe "police excess and firing" if the government-appointed judicial panel does not table its report soon. Four people died, including a Kargil war veteran, on 24 September 2025 in Leh.
  • He also criticised the compensation (₹15 lakh for each death, ₹3 lakh for the injured), the pace of withdrawal of cases, and the 9 September MHA meeting. He said the meeting merely repeated the 22 May proposal for a tailor-made (sui generis) governance arrangement with Article 371 safeguards.
  • He announced a one-day, 20-km symbolic padayatra on 23 September from Karu to the Martyrs' Memorial Park, Leh.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: Constitutional safeguards for UTs (Art. 371/Sixth Schedule), federalism, accountability for use of force

Key facts for Prelims

  • Art. 371 (Part XXI) gives special provisions for certain States. The Sixth Schedule (Arts 244(2), 275(1)) covers autonomous councils in Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura and Mizoram.
  • Ladakh is a UT without a legislature (since 31 October 2019) and is not under the Sixth Schedule.
  • Art. 240 empowers the President to make regulations for peace, progress and good government of certain UTs (static fact).
  • The proposed "Article 371K" or Chapter K under Art. 371 is a new constitutional provision for Ladakh and would need a constitutional amendment (Art. 368).
  • Sui generis means "of its own kind", a bespoke arrangement.
  • Commissions of Inquiry Act, 1952: report to be laid before the legislature with an action-taken memorandum.
  • Bodies: LAB (Leh Apex Body); KDA (Kargil Democratic Alliance); HPC (High-Powered Committee).

Data and details

  • Deaths: four people, including a Kargil war veteran, on 24 September 2025.
  • MHA notified the inquiry on 17 October 2025 (Justice B.S. Chauhan). He was also appointed in February to head the three-member Commission of Inquiry on the 2023 Manipur ethnic violence.
  • Wangchuk: affidavits and submissions before the inquiry were completed long ago. No date has been announced for the findings. He did not depose personally because he was in jail during the proceedings.
  • He alleges automatic weapons were used on protesters with no firing orders.
  • Compensation: ₹15 lakh for a death and ₹3 lakh for injured. He compares it with ₹1 crore that, he says, was agreed in Delhi.
  • Padayatra: one day, 20 km, on 23 September; starts at Karu (where villagers built a sthupa in memory of one of those killed) and ends at Martyrs' Memorial Park, Leh at about 6 p.m. A longer march was dropped owing to bad weather.
  • 9 September MHA meeting: he says it was a PowerPoint repeating the 22 May proposal, with hardly anything new. The groups had sent their "non-negotiable points" for inclusion in the draft and expected detailed drafts in September.
  • He says the meeting was scheduled to dissuade people from the padayatra beginning the next day, and questions an October round of talks as September is a commemoration month in Ladakh.
  • He hopes the governance model will be placed before Parliament in the winter session.
  • Former BJP MP Thupstan Chhewang (one of the first leaders to launch the 2020 movement for safeguards) accused Wangchuk of misleading people. Wangchuk says Chhewang resigned from the LAB and attended the talks only as a special invitee.
  • Cases: the groups want all criminal cases withdrawn at once, not in phases. He says several of those booked were bystanders or had tried to stop the clashes.
  • The LAB and KDA also want no far-reaching decisions on land, industries and local governance while talks continue.
  • Demands under negotiation: constitutional safeguards, greater political representation, and protection of land and employment rights.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Ladakh became a UT after the reorganisation of J&K and has no legislature. The local demand is for protection of land, jobs, culture and political voice.
  • The Sixth Schedule creates autonomous district/regional councils for tribal areas. Art. 371 and its sub-articles give special provisions tailored to particular States. Whether Ladakh gets either (or a new bespoke article) is the heart of the talks.
  • Judicial inquiries into police firing are meant to establish facts and accountability. If findings are not made public, their purpose is weakened.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Union Territories; special provisions for certain States (Part XXI, Art. 371 series); Sixth Schedule; federalism and asymmetric autonomy; Commissions of Inquiry; accountability of security forces. GS3 – internal security (policing of protests).

Background primer

Article 371 and the Sixth Schedule

What it is:
Art. 371 (Part XXI) provides special provisions for certain States, to meet unique historical, cultural, social and regional needs. Part XXI is titled Temporary, Transitional and Special Provisions.
Founded:
the Sixth Schedule is part of the original Constitution (1950, under Arts 244(2) and 275(1)). The State-specific provisions from Art. 371A onwards were added over time by constitutional amendments, beginning with Art. 371A (Nagaland) in 1962.
Mandate:
asymmetric federalism, which means safeguards in land, culture, jobs or administration for specific regions.
Why it matters:
protecting distinct identities and vulnerable communities within a single constitutional framework.

Ladakh's demands and talks structure

What it is:
Ladakh became a Union Territory on 31 October 2019 after the reorganisation of the former State of Jammu and Kashmir.

Judicial Inquiry on the 24 September 2025 Leh incident

Additional context

  • The MHA added Rigzin Spalgon, Additional Secretary in the UT administration, as Joint Secretary to the inquiry, following a representation by the LAB for a local member.
  • The Commission began recording oral statements on 19 December 2025.
  • The 22 May proposal (per the MHA's released minutes) envisaged a sui generis self-governance model drawing on Art. 371, with an elected UT-level body having legislative, executive and financial powers, instead of the Sixth Schedule.
  • On 9 September 2026 the MHA proposed a new Chapter K under Article 371 for Ladakh: a directly elected UT-level body for land, culture, language, forests, environment and Art. 240 matters. The MHA deferred decisions on executive, financial, planning and law-and-order powers.
  • Measures the Government has cited so far include raising Scheduled Tribe reservation in Ladakh from 45% to 84%, one-third reservation for women in the Ladakh Autonomous Hill Development Councils (LAHDCs), and recognition of Bhoti and Purgi as official languages.
  • Five new districts (Sham, Nubra, Changthang, Zanskar and Drass) were created in April 2026, with 17 new tehsils added.

Mains dimensions

  • Accountability for use of force: four deaths and an allegation of automatic weapons used without firing orders put the spotlight on proportionality, command responsibility and the legality of firing on crowds. A year on, there is no public report.
  • Transparency of inquiry reports: the inquiry has been completed in terms of evidence (according to Wangchuk), yet findings are not public. The threat of a parallel "people's tribunal" shows the cost to trust when state-appointed bodies are slow, and a non-statutory tribunal has no legal power.
  • Quantum of compensation: the groups call ₹15 lakh and ₹3 lakh inadequate, contrasting it with the ₹1 crore Wangchuk says was agreed in Delhi. This raises questions about how compensation is fixed and whether it was settled with the affected families and groups.
  • Negotiation process: the 9 September meeting, as described, was a repeat of 22 May, with drafts not shared. The Centre offers a sui generis Art. 371-type model, whereas the groups sought statehood and Sixth Schedule status. The talks show the gap between a bespoke UT-level body and constitutionally guaranteed powers.
  • Federalism and UT design: the proposed new Art. 371K-type provision would be a first for a UT without a legislature, bringing asymmetry into the UT framework. It tests the rule of constitutional amendment (Art. 368).
  • Confidence-building: phased vs complete withdrawal of cases, alleged booking of bystanders, and the timing of talks in a month of mourning all affect trust. The groups' demand to freeze major decisions on land, industries and governance protects the status quo during negotiations.
  • Representation within the movement: the Chhewang–Wangchuk dispute on who represents the LAB shows the difficulty of negotiating with a coalition of Leh and Kargil bodies.
  • Strategic context: Ladakh is a sensitive border region, so autonomy design is also a security question (analytical point; not from the article).

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "Examine the demand for constitutional safeguards for Ladakh, comparing the Sixth Schedule with an Article 371-type arrangement. How can the Centre balance regional autonomy, local identity and national security?"

Related topics

  • Part XXI (Arts 369–392): Art. 371, 371A–371J; Sixth Schedule and Autonomous District Councils
  • Union Territories (Art. 239–241); Art. 240; J&K Reorganisation Act, 2019
  • Commissions of Inquiry Act, 1952; accountability for police firing
  • Asymmetric federalism; Art. 368 (amendment procedure)
  • Cross-reference: Manipur inquiry (same former judge)

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 23 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs