Reiterating the basics of criminalisation
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 23 September 2026
Summary
- On 20 August a two-judge SC Bench (Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran) ruled in Shiv Pratap Singh v. State of U.P. and Himanshu Srivastava v. State of U.P. that the Uttar Pradesh Gangsters and Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 1986 is "still-born". Proceedings under it cannot survive.
- The Court held that who is a "gangster" for the purpose of punishment is left to the "ipse dixit" of the executive through Rules. The creation of a crime is a legislative function and cannot be left to subordinate legislation.
- The author calls the ruling laudable. He says it reiterates the basics of criminalisation and sets out an agenda for reforming the Act.
Key facts for Prelims
- Art. 20(1): no ex post facto criminal law and no penalty greater than that under the law in force at the time of the offence. Art. 20(2) is double jeopardy and Art. 20(3) is protection against self-incrimination.
- Legislative function: the definition of offences is for the legislature. The delegate (executive) can only fill in procedure and details.
- The UP Gangsters Act, 1986 is a State Act. The editorial says the SC held it "still-born" on 20 August.
- The General Clauses Act, 1897 contains the definition of "offence", which the SC applied in the case.
- Maxims: nullum crimen sine lege; nulla poena sine lege.
- Rules made under an Act are subordinate (delegated) legislation. Ultra vires is the main ground to challenge them.
Data and details
- The Act dealt with gangsters in UP "for four decades" (1986 Act).
- Ruling: 20 August; two-judge Bench of Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran; cases Shiv Pratap Singh v. State of U.P. and Himanshu Srivastava v. State of U.P.
- Quoted holding (author's report): the Act is "still-born" and proceedings under it cannot survive.
- On the General Clauses Act test, the Court said it could not find any offence having been created.
- Where status is determined by the administrative and police authorities by preparing a gang chart, the Court said nothing remains for the judicial officer but to punish. The result of the trial is a "foregone conclusion", a "statutory imprimatur to punish".
- The Court also said that however grave the social menace, penal enactments cannot lead to arbitrary and capricious action against the accused.
- Herbert L. Packer, The Limits of the Criminal Sanction (1968): the definitional role belongs primarily and broadly to the legislature, secondarily and interstitially to the courts, and to no one else.
- Examples of "name-calling at will" the author cites: deshdrohi and "urban naxal".
Static–dynamic linkage
- The principle of legality rests on nullum crimen sine lege (no crime without law), nulla poena sine lege (no punishment without law) and the ban on ex post facto penal laws.
- Art. 20(1): no conviction except for violation of a law in force at the time of the act, and no penalty greater than the law then prescribed.
- Defining crime and punishment is a legislative function (Parliament or the State Legislature). The legislature may delegate details, but not the essential legislative function of deciding what is criminal.
- Delegated legislation (Rules) can be challenged for lack of legislative competence, for violating fundamental rights or other constitutional provisions, or for being ultra vires the parent Act.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Separation of powers; Judiciary; Art. 20(1) and the principle of legality; delegated legislation. GS3/GS2 – criminal law reform.
Background primer
Uttar Pradesh Gangsters and Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 1986
- What it is:
- an Act to make special provisions for preventing and coping with gangsters and anti-social activities. It was enacted as Act 7 of 1986.
- Mandate:
- to prevent gang-related and anti-social activities, with preventive action, including detention, and attachment of property acquired through crime.
- Why it matters:
- special procedures and tougher penalties for gang crime. The SC's verdict centres on whether the Act itself defines the offence or leaves it to executive Rules.
Principle of legality / Art. 20(1)
- What it is:
- the rule that conduct is punishable only if a pre-existing, clearly defined law makes it an offence.
- Founded:
- constitutionalised in Art. 20(1); it draws on classical maxims (as the editorial notes).
- Mandate:
- to protect against arbitrary, retrospective or executively created criminality.
- Why it matters:
- certainty, fair notice and democratic deliberation before liberty is curtailed.
Additional context
- The UP Gangsters and Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Rules, 2021 provide the detailed guidelines for implementing the Act. They require the competent authority, usually the District Magistrate, to record satisfaction while forwarding and approving gang charts.
- Section 3(1) of the Act prescribes imprisonment of not less than two years, extendable to ten years, and a fine of at least ₹5,000.
- Earlier litigation: in an earlier SC judgment the constitutional validity of Section 12 of the Act was upheld, as not infringing Arts 14 and 21. In Shraddha Gupta v. State of U.P. (2022), the SC held that an accused can be termed a "gangster" when, as a member of a gang, he has engaged in any of the enumerated activities.
Mains dimensions
- Legality: an offence must be created by the Act itself. The U.P. Act defines "gangster" but leaves the determination of who is one to Rules, which the Court said hands decisive power to the executive.
- Separation of powers: criminal lawmaking is a legislative function, and the Court refused to let it "sprout in the thicket" of subordinate legislation. This protects debate and deliberation at the stage of enactment.
- Status-based punishment: the gang chart, prepared by administrative and police authorities, effectively decides guilt. The Court found that the trial becomes a formality, so judicial determination is displaced.
- Executive discretion and evidence: the editorial says challenges repeatedly argue that executive authorities reach conclusions of culpability without verifiable evidence or reasoning.
- Social menace vs liberty: the Court's line that no menace, however grave, justifies arbitrary action is a statement of due process.
- Loose labelling: the author contrasts the Court's insistence on clear definitions with a society used to "name-calling" (deshdrohi, "urban naxal"). Clarity in defining categories protects against stigma and arbitrary use.
- Wider reform: other State laws with similar structures (special offences with rule-based categorisation) may face similar scrutiny. The author says the ruling lays out an agenda for reforming the Gangster Act.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "Criminal law-making is an exclusively legislative function. In light of the Supreme Court's recent ruling on the U.P. Gangsters Act, discuss the principle of legality and the limits of delegated legislation in penal statutes."
Related topics
- Art. 20(1), Art. 14, Art. 21; Art. 22 (preventive detention)
- Delegated legislation and excessive delegation; Rules and ultra vires
- Separation of powers; judicial review of legislation
- Organised crime laws (MCOCA-type State laws, BNS organised crime provisions); presumption and burden of proof in special statutes
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 23 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs