Karnataka Houses adopt resolution against report on Western Ghats
Source: The Hindu, 23 September 2026
Summary
- On Tuesday (22 Sept) both Houses of Karnataka's Legislature, the Assembly and the Council, unanimously adopted a resolution on the Centre's Western Ghats ESA proposal. It follows the Kasturirangan report.
- The resolution asks the Union government to confine the ESA to notified forests only.
- It also asks that the draft notification not be finalised for a year, until a physical survey is done.
Key facts for Prelims
- ESAs/ESZs are notified by the environment ministry (MoEFCC). The power comes from Section 3 of the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, which does not itself use the term "Eco-Sensitive Zones".
- Gadgil Committee (WGEEP, 2011) vs. Kasturirangan HLWG (report 2013). A past Prelims question (2016) asked what the two reports relate to; the answer is protection of the Western Ghats.
- Kasturirangan HLWG: only about 37% (roughly 60,000 sq. km) of the Western Ghats under ESA. The Gadgil panel had proposed the entire Western Ghats as ESA, graded into ESZ-1, 2 and 3.
- The Western Ghats ESA spans six States: Karnataka, Kerala, Goa, Maharashtra, Gujarat, Tamil Nadu.
- Forum/body: both Houses of a State Legislature (Assembly + Council, i.e. Vidhan Sabha + Vidhan Parishad) passed the resolution. Karnataka has a bicameral legislature.
- A legislative resolution is a non-binding expression of the State's position. It does not legally bind the Union.
Data and details
- The Centre issued the seventh draft ESA notification on July 27.
- Area in Karnataka: 20,668 sq. km across 1,449 villages in 10 districts.
- Karnataka's stand would cut this to about 16,000 sq. km.
- Karnataka asks for one year to complete a physical survey of the ESA areas.
- The resolution says the final decision should come only after the State submits its report and after detailed discussion between the Centre and the State.
- Karnataka will constitute a high-level committee to suggest modifications to correct "lacunae" in the report.
- Karnataka's core allegation: the ESA was determined from satellite data rather than a joint physical survey by the Forest and Revenue departments, so it is not accurate.
- The resolution was unanimous in both the Assembly and the Council.
Static–dynamic linkage
- An Ecologically Sensitive Area is a conservation tool under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986. The Union environment ministry notifies it by draft and then final notification. This follows a prescribed consultation process before the notification takes effect.
- The tension is between ecological protection of a biodiversity hotspot and local livelihoods and development.
- Land and forest use, agriculture, and local administration of revenue villages sit with the States. This is why the Centre's notification needs State buy-in, and why boundary-setting methodology (satellite vs. ground survey) becomes a federal bargaining point.
Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Environment: conservation, eco-sensitive areas, environmental governance; GS2 – Polity: Centre–State relations, role of State legislatures
Background primer
Kasturirangan High-Level Working Group (HLWG) on the Western Ghats
- What it is:
- A 10-member High-Level Working Group chaired by Dr. K. Kasturirangan, formed by the environment ministry to examine the earlier Gadgil-led Western Ghats Ecology Expert Panel (WGEEP) report and chart a balanced roadmap between conservation and development. Its report was submitted in April 2013.
- Founded:
- The HLWG was constituted in August 2012 under Dr. K. Kasturirangan, a former Planning Commission member. It was set up to review the Gadgil panel, whose recommendations had faced strong opposition from States and stakeholders as overly restrictive on development. That opposition was the reason for the second review.
Additional context
-
The 7th draft proposes an ESA of 56,825.7 sq. km across six States. Karnataka has the largest share (20,668 sq. km) and Gujarat the smallest (449 sq. km).
-
It prohibits commercial mining, stone quarrying, sand mining, new thermal power plants, "red category" industries and large-scale construction. It clarifies that agriculture, plantation activity and local livelihoods remain unaffected.
-
The draft allows phased, State-wise or combined notification, without waiting for consensus from all six States.
-
An expert committee headed by Sanjay Kumar (formed 2022) is examining State objections and village-demarcation discrepancies. Its tenure has been extended to July 2027.
-
In the 2014 draft, the Centre used the ESA demarcated by Kerala for Kerala. For the other States it used the HLWG-recommended area.
Mains dimensions
- Federalism and consultation. The Centre notifies ESAs, but their impact is on State subjects such as land, agriculture and revenue villages. Karnataka insists on a final decision only after State submission and detailed Centre–State discussion. A cross-party unanimous vote signals that the issue is politically non-negotiable at State level.
- Methodology. Satellite-based demarcation vs. a joint physical survey by Forest and Revenue departments. The State's demand for a joint physical survey reflects disputes over village-level demarcation, which the Sanjay Kumar expert committee is also examining.
- Livelihoods vs conservation. Karnataka wants the ESA reduced from 20,668 to about 16,000 sq. km, confined to notified forests. Risk: this leaves out corridors and non-forest ecological patches that matter for hydrology and wildlife.
- Regulatory limbo. Seven drafts since 2014 without a final notification create uncertainty for both conservation and residents, and invite repeated State resistance.
- Way forward. Joint ground survey, graded regulation (strict in core forests, lighter in livelihood zones), payments for ecosystem services (a Kasturirangan report idea), Gram Sabha-level participation (the bottom-up governance the Gadgil panel stressed), and a time-bound consultation calendar.
Possible Mains question
**GS3 (Environment) / GS2 (Federalism), 15 marks:** "The repeated re-issue of draft notifications on the Western Ghats Ecologically Sensitive Area shows the difficulty of reconciling conservation with development in a federal setup. Examine, with reference to the Gadgil and Kasturirangan reports."
Related topics
- Environment (Protection) Act, 1986; Eco-Sensitive Zones around protected areas
- EIA Notification, 2006; National Green Tribunal
- Forest Rights Act, 2006 and Gram Sabha consent
- Western Ghats as a UNESCO World Heritage Site and biodiversity hotspot
- Centre–State relations (Seventh Schedule: forests, agriculture, land)
Topics: GS3Environment
All current affairs of 23 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs