Cannot penalise refusal to sing National Song: SC
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 23 September 2026
Summary
- A three-judge SC Bench headed by CJI Surya Kant sought the Union's reply on T.M. Krishna's petition against the Prevention of Insults to National Honour (Amendment) Act, 2026 and the Home Ministry's January directions and July circular. Justice Joymalya Bagchi observed that the State may decide the scope and length of the National Song, but cannot infringe Arts 25 and 26 or penalise a conscientious objector.
- Justice Bagchi said the 1986 Bijoe Emmanuel v. State of Kerala precedent on religious freedom, constitutional tolerance and silent objection still holds.
- Separately, Karnataka Governor Thaawarchand Gehlot asked CM D.K. Shivakumar to reconsider the 8 September Government Order limiting Vande Mataram to two stanzas at State functions. He said it contradicts Union guidelines and the 2026 Act, and that the matter is outside State legislative competence.
Key facts for Prelims
- Arts 25 and 26: Art. 25 is freedom of conscience and religion; Art. 26 is the right of religious denominations to manage their religious affairs. Art. 51A(a) is the Fundamental Duty to respect the Constitution, National Flag and National Anthem.
- Bijoe Emmanuel v. State of Kerala (1986): standing but not singing the Anthem is not an offence under the PINH Act.
- PINH Act, 1971 — Section 2 (Flag, Constitution), Section 3 (Anthem; Song after 2026), Section 3A (repeat offenders, minimum one year).
- The Constitution does not explicitly mention a National Song. Dr Rajendra Prasad's statement of 24 January 1950 accorded Vande Mataram equal honour with Jana Gana Mana.
- Governor acts on aid and advice of the Council of Ministers (Art. 163), except in matters of discretion.
- Secularism is part of the basic structure; the petition invokes this.
Data and details
- Penalty under the challenged scheme, as the petitioner states: up to three years' imprisonment, fine, or both. All six stanzas of Vande Mataram are said to be compelled before the National Anthem at public functions.
- The petitioner says stanzas 3–6 are devotional and deity-invoking.
- Challenged instruments: the 2026 Act (amended Section 3), MHA administrative directions of January, and a circular of July. Karnataka's Government Order is dated 8 September.
- The petitioner's counsel (S. Muralidhar and Prasanna S.) said the Home Ministry's office memorandum was never gazetted and cites no supporting provision of law.
- The petitioner's counsel also said the 2026 Act does not define the "National Song".
- CJI Kant said anyone who reads history knows what the National Song is. Solicitor-General Tushar Mehta said it has been the National Song since pre-Independence, and Justice Bagchi said customs and usages could also establish this.
- Justice Bagchi said religious flavour or homage to a deity may not by itself impair secularism, and cited the American national anthem's reference to "God" as an example of positive secularism.
- Justice Bagchi said the Court is often loath to articulate national aspirations or second-guess nationalism. Even so, it will examine whether the 2026 amendment and the circulars choke conscientious objectors' rights.
- The SG remarked "let us not bag the National Song in sensationalism". He also objected that lawmaking is done "as per the Constitution", not as per "Naxalites' idea". Counsel called this offensive and unbecoming of a law officer.
- Karnataka Governor's letter: the GO is contrary to Union guidelines and the 2026 Act, and falls outside State legislative competence. He called it constitutionally and administratively inappropriate for a State to prescribe a truncated rendition for its functions without first reconciling it with the central framework.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Art. 25 guarantees freedom of conscience and the right to profess, practise and propagate religion, subject to public order, morality and health. It is also subject to the other Fundamental Rights.
- Bijoe Emmanuel separates respect from compelled participation. Standing respectfully while not singing is not disrespect. State symbols can be honoured without forcing recitation against conscience.
- Penal law must be clear (legality, Art. 20(1)), and executive circulars without statutory backing cannot create penal consequences.
- Under federal design, the Governor acts on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers (Art. 163), except where the Constitution gives discretion. A Governor's public letter urging reconsideration of a State order is a point of constitutional propriety.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Fundamental Rights (Arts 19(1)(a), 25, 26); secularism as basic structure; Fundamental Duties (Art. 51A); executive orders vs law; Centre–State relations; Governor's role.
Background primer
Prevention of Insults to National Honour Act, 1971 (PINH Act)
- What it is:
- a central statute (Act 69 of 1971) enacted on 23 December 1971 that gives statutory protection to the National Flag, the Constitution and the National Anthem.
National Song (Vande Mataram)
- What it is:
- a patriotic song by Bankim Chandra Chattopadhyay, composed in Sanskritised Bengali and included in his novel *Anandamath* (1882).
- Why it matters:
- its role in the freedom struggle and the Swadeshi movement.
Bijoe Emmanuel v. State of Kerala (1986)
Additional context
- Executive directions: the MHA's directions say the official version of Vande Mataram has all six stanzas (about 3 minutes 10 seconds), to be used at specified official occasions. When both are played, Vande Mataram precedes Jana Gana Mana. Earlier, generally only the first two stanzas were used.
- On 9 July 2026 the MHA directed States and central ministries to play Vande Mataram before Jana Gana Mana and to use all six stanzas at official events.
- The guidelines require the audience to stand to attention, except where the song is part of a newsreel or documentary.
- One analysis notes that as amended, Section 3 does not expressly require anyone to sing Vande Mataram, and the law does not specify which stanzas must be sung. The petition's compulsion argument therefore rests on the Act read with the executive directions.
- The Centre has been observing a year-long national commemoration of the song's 150th anniversary, from November 2025.
Mains dimensions
- Conscientious objection: the Bench draws the line at penal consequences. The State may fix the form of the song, but refusal of recitation must not lead to prosecution, which follows Bijoe Emmanuel.
- Compelled speech: the right to silence is part of Art. 19(1)(a), and the petition says mandatory mass singing under penal sanction amounts to compelled assent.
- Secularism: the petition says stanzas 3–6 are devotional and non-secular. The Bench's remark about "positive secularism" suggests it will test whether religious imagery in a national symbol is by itself unconstitutional, or only compulsion is.
- Rule of law and executive overreach: the office memorandum was reportedly never gazetted and cites no provision of law, and the Act reportedly does not define "National Song". Penal consequences cannot flow from unpublished or undefined executive instructions.
- Law-making process: the petitioner says a definition needs broader debate and consensus. The SG's reply, and the sharp exchange over its tone, shows how politicised the symbol has become. The Bench said it was not there "to create sensations".
- Federalism: the Karnataka GO (two stanzas) conflicts with the Union's six-stanza directions. The Governor's letter treats it as beyond State competence. The episode raises the question of the Governor's role and the limits of Union executive directions to States.
- Judicial role: the Court has issued notice and sought the Union's response, and has framed the issue narrowly as the rights of conscientious objectors, not the status of the song.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "Can the State compel participation in national symbols through penal law? Examine in light of *Bijoe Emmanuel* and the recent controversy over the National Song."
Related topics
- Arts 19(1)(a), 25, 26, 51A(a); secularism and basic structure
- Right to silence and compelled speech
- Art. 20(1) (legality) and delegated/executive legislation without gazette notification
- Governor: Art. 163 (aid and advice), Art. 154
- Centre–State relations; legislative competence (Seventh Schedule)
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 23 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs